Austro-Libertarian Natural Order Philosophy From Indyeah

Individualistic Austro-Libertarian Natural Order Philosophy From Indyeah

Monday, November 3, 2008

On Sandalwood... And Ganja

There is news today that some "sandalwood smugglers" have been apprehended by the Chennai police. They cut down sandalwood trees in the sprawling 300 acre campus of the Theosophical Society. The report notes that there are other institutions nearby, including the Madras Christian College, that have huge campuses where sandalwood grows.

My point is simply this: If sandalwood grows so easily in Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, and all along the Western Ghats, why should this resource not be treated as private property of whoever owns the land on which it is growing?

The problem today is that sandalwood is "collective property" and our The State owns all the sandalwood. If this tree was farmed, every poor person would plant a sapling in his compound, tend to it with loving care, and sell it at maturity to help in his old age. If this logic is applied to all trees - teak, sal, ebony, mahogany, rosewood, pine etc. - then it would be win-win all around. Timber is a renewable resource that should be cheap. With private property governing tree farming, timber would be abundant. It is scarce today, hence unaffordable, because of State ownership. And, of course, there are all these needless problems for the police - who could focus their energies on combating real crime.

I was the only person in India to write this when Veerappan was murdered without trial by the Karnataka Police. This article was translated into Kannada and immediately republished in a leading Kannada daily - that too, as front page anchor. I am glad to see that it has also appeared in Tamil.

Of course, I MUST add that if people can grow what they like on their properties and sell their crops freely, then ganja farming should also be totally legit.

"The Weed" Must Become "The Crop"!

6 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sauvik,
    A bit of pedantry here - Verappan was killed by the Special Task Force of Tamil Nadu Police, not by the Karnataka Police. An extra-judicial killing, as the press would say.

    Hari

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sometime last month a person was killed by forest guards in Bannerghatta park near Bangalore. I was browsing for some info then and came across this good article.

    Even I feel sympathetic towards Veerappan nowadays :|

    ReplyDelete
  4. I cannot agree less on what you say about the need for radical change in the way we approach timber as a resource in the country. On a lighter note, allow me to take you a little further. I would like you to come with me up north of the country where there is abundant weed farming in Himachal Pradesh, now being practised by both local and global cronies using the country’s most successful typical method called ‘setting’. This nexus successfully encroaches into the private farms as well as the difficult to monitor public/government land. Dope is not a big thing in Himanchal when the preserver and the protector of the weed is the big name of Lord Shiva itself. Also, please let me add - there is no need for private fencing, it grows six feet just like that, and can be see down the next hill. If one drives through the highway, he can observe the head down donkeys - still and eyes closed - their belly probably stuffed with illegit hay. The point is – the stuff is not supposed to be free, but is freely available. Maybe, the issue needs some free thinking now. Just like wood.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Why only timberwood?

    Why not water resources?

    Why not mines?

    Anyways I support your idea.

    here are some more cases
    Private Roads
    Water Crisis In India
    Case of private ownership of Natural Resources--1
    Case of private ownership of Natural Resources--2

    .

    .

    ReplyDelete
  6. umm don't consider me a spam.

    Just I wanted to confer similar ideas with a rational and strong point of view, that's why I put up those article's url.

    ReplyDelete