Nilekani's UID - Passport To Totalitarianism & A Police State

Before assessing Nandan Nilekani's UID (Unique Identity) Scheme for iris-mapping and fingerprinting each one of us for Police Records, it might be useful to read Wendy McElroy's recent article against passports titled "Passport to a Total State." UID could be a means to convert our totally failed The State into a Total Police State. McElroy, a US citizen, begins thus:

"Your papers!" In old movies, the demand is barked at trembling travelers by a Nazi with a guttural accent. If the demand is made in the opening scene, then the audience knows immediately that they watching a totalitarian state in which travelers are in danger.

"Your papers!" now rings out at every American airport and border crossing. The accent is different but travelers need to recognize with equal immediacy that a totalitarian state is playing out in front of their eyes, and they must be careful.

McElroy asserts: "It is the mandatory nature of any travel document that converts it into a violation of rights." UID will be mandatory, too.

  

She adds: "With the exception of trespassing on private property, people have an absolute right to travel in peace and at their own discretion." 


And she ends her piece with these ringing words:

The passport has grown into what is arguably the single most powerful tool of totalitarian America, second only to law enforcement [read "legislation-enforcement"] itself. It no longer pretends to protect individuals; not a single terrorist has been apprehended as a result of passport checks. But it does cement the totalitarian state. The mandatory passport should be reviled and rejected as an abuse of human rights and common decency. A nation that requires one cannot be free.

 In my life I have never suffered more than at the hands of passport officials and, of course, their counterparts, the visa officials. And The Police, of course. 


The question is: Do we strengthen these bastards? Or, do we get RID of them?


In my book, in a market economy, citizens must have secrets, including especially business secrets. Bank accounts must be secret - as they were in Switzerland once-upon-a-time. 


On the other hand, whatever is done in the political-bureaucratic sphere must be completely OPEN. No "official secrets."


Think about it.


Song of the Day: Mr. Bob Marley, of course, singing:

Why can't we roam,

This Open Country?

Why can't we be

What we want to be?

WE WANT TO BE FREE!

Hey! Mr. Cop,

Ain't got no Birth Cerfiticate (sic) on me now...

You can watch the video of this great song here.