Austro-Libertarian Natural Order Philosophy From Indyeah

Individualistic Austro-Libertarian Natural Order Philosophy From Indyeah
Showing posts with label Naxalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Naxalism. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Continue With Rural Development? The Same Old Crap! Or Urbanisation Powered By Unilateral Free Trade?



What is the greatest threat to our lives: Terrorists or Maoists?


I would say: ROAD TRAFFIC!


200,000 people die on our unsafe roads every year, and many times more are seriously injured.


But at a a national workshop on rural development programmes in areas most affected by the Maoist movement, our Central State Police Minister, Palaniappan Chidambaram, said that Maoists are a bigger threat than terrorists - while forgetting all about road traffic deaths, of course.


The news report says:


In the first eight months of this year, the number of civilians killed by Maoists is 10 times more than those killed in terror attacks, he [Chidambaram] said at a national workshop on rural development programmes in areas most affected by the rebel movement.


The one-day "workshop," held in Nude Elly, was attended by all the top brass connected with "rural development": first, the Rural Development Minister, Jairam Ramesh, a political flyweight, Rajya Sabha MP from Andhra Pradesh; there was Montek, who heads the Planning Commission, the "economist"; there was minister for road transport and highways C.P. Joshi and tribal affairs and panchayati raj minister V. Kishore Chandra Deo.


The Annual Budget for rural development is 87,800 crore rupees. (One crore is 10 million.)


The news report says:



The rural development ministry is the nodal agency for development schemes, including the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS), the Indira Awas Yojana, the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY) and the National Rural Livelihood Mission. It has been allocated 87,800 crore rupees in the year to 31 March to implement these programmes. This includes the allocation to the department of drinking water and sanitation.
s.

But, obviously, all this SHIT is not working - because it cannot. Economic Law cannot be violated. Economic Law says the "division of labour" - which is the "specialisation" by which wealth is created - is maximised in cities and towns, because there are bigger markets there, because population density is high. A tea-shop in Pondicherry earns much more than a tea-shop in the jungles of Jharkhand - and it is not surprising that there are migrants from Jharkhand to be found in Pondicherry (I met two young boys) as also in Nude Elly. In Nude Elly, in fact, girls from Jharkhand are to be found working as housemaids. They have their own church in Green Park, where they meet their fellow Jharkhandis on Sundays, worship, socialise, and exchange news.


Nothing much can be achieved by spending 87,800 crore rupees on Rural Development. It is just "pork barrel politics." Corruption. It is interesting that chacha manmohan s gandhi bravely told the audience at this workshop that "there must be 'zero tolerance for corruption' in the implementation of schemes intended for these regions." Then how come he "tolerates" so much corruption in his own Cabinet?


There is ANOTHER WAY - and that is URBAN DEVELOPMENT, that too, along the twin coastlines, powered by unilateral free trade.


So, imagine a libertarian politician at the helm making a speech to the Jharkhandis:


Ladies and gentlemen,


There is NO HOPE for you in these jungles. If you want to progress, you must shift to where the MARKET beckons - and that is the COAST. So, go, all you tough young men and women, go to a coastal town or city of your choice and engage in free international trade. Come home with your profits - and return again.


For those who cannot go or do not want to go, government handouts are NOT the solution. Government CANNOT create jobs. But government can DESTROY jobs - by overtaxation, by restrictive licensing, and by the OUTRIGHT BANNING of trades.

Your trades in MAHUA and HANDIA are banned because of the previous government. We are setting them FREE - alongwith ganja. Sell these lovely drinks and smokes to tourists. Let there be mahua plantations instead of tendu leaf collection. Smoke cigarettes. Smoke ganja.


And remember: If you want tourists to come, there must be PEACE. No tourist will come to where he can get SHOT! That is why there are no tourists in KABUL these days.


So say OM SHANTI. And let there be peace.


Oppose the Maoists - tooth-and-nail. They are zeroes even in CHINA!


It is either Capitalism - which requires peace.


Or Communism - which requires WAR.


Choose ladies and gentlemen.


(Wild cheering.)


Get my drift, dudes?


MORONS ON TOP!

Thursday, June 2, 2011

Bengal - As A "Nation Of Shopkeepers"

While some have concluded, quite correctly, that the West Bengal elections were won and lost on the issue of Private Property, this blog took the point further and argued that, for the new regime, road-construction must be a top priority, because roads automatically increase the value of lands they link to. Oddly enough, the news has it that the Mamata Banerjee government has 35 ministers - but no mention is made of a roads minister!

Today, there is another piece of news from Calcutta that suggests roads must be top priority. Referring to Calcutta's street hawkers, this news report concludes with the following paragraph:

The Chief Minister said she had been holding discussions with officials concerned for improving the traffic system that would entail, among other things, widening of some roads without evicting hawkers on the pavements.

Why are there so many street hawkers in Calcutta? Two reasons: First, Calcutta is the only Big City - and so it attracts migrants like a magnet; and second, these migrants cannot afford to buy shops. How will roads help?

With roads into the surrounds, satellite towns would develop, and more and more commercial property would be built, bringing down the cost of shops. In time, more and more of these hawkers would become regular shop-owners. That is the direction in which Bengal must proceed - build roads so as to urbanise aggressively; and put an end to zoning rules so that commercial property grows without any legal restrictions.

The West was also like this. I recall visiting the ancient City of Cologne in Germany some years back, and walking about its markets with a local journalist who told me that, in the olden days, one of the legal responsibilities of the City Mayor was to oversee the smooth conduct of all business on the streets: that is, business conducted by street hawkers and vendors. 

My guide told me that in ancient times, poor people from afar would travel to Cologne to sell their wares in its markets - and the Mayor had to look after their interests. But now, said my guide, everyone owns a shop - and this legal responsibility has recently been deleted from the duties of the City Mayor. The same can happen in West Bengal - a state that has many big cities and towns apart from Calcutta. Economic progress ought to mean that street-hawkers become shopkeepers.

Of course, western cities still have informal markets and street hawkers can still be found - as in Amsterdam - but these are run by quite prosperous folk, and they rake in bigger profits than regular shopkeepers because tourists prefer to shop in such informal markets. And overhead costs in informal markets are quite low.

It is also my opinion that aiming for a Bengal that is a "nation of shopkeepers" would totally destroy the appeal of Communism, which has held the average Bengali in its thrall for decades - and encouraged him to become a government clerk: a baboo. Indeed, the very word is Bengali. 

Bengal was the first province in India to be ruled by by the British - and it was Napoleon who ridiculed the British by calling them "a nation of shopkeepers." Napoleon preferred France to be "a nation of patriotic soldiers" - but it was Britain and not France that emerged victorious. It was the nation of shopkeepers that ruled the world. Mises says something noteworthy about these shopkeepers - and the civilisation they begat:

The much abused shopkeepers have abolished slavery and serfdom, made woman the companion of man with equal rights, proclaimed equality before the law and freedom of thought and opinion, declared war on war, abolished torture, and mitigated the cruelty of punishment. What cultural force can boast of similar achievements?

The Brits built all the great markets of Calcutta - the very old "New Market" was built by Sir Stuart Hogg - and a section of it is still named after him.

Bengal has voted for poriborton - or "change." Let that change first emerge in ideology. Let Capitalism replace Communism.  The common people of West Bengal, the peasants and the workers, swallowed all the commie propaganda - and lost. Lost badly. For them, I have another noteworthy quote from Mises:

There is but one way toward an increase of real wage rates for all those eager to earn wages: the progressive accumulation of new capital and the improvement of technical methods of production which the new capital brings about. The true interests of labor coincide with those of business.

So, it not only Private Property that matters for Bengal's future. It is the entire Capitalist prescription that needs to be implemented - beginning with Free Trade, so that all the swanking new shops will have shelves overflowing with the best goods from all over the world. Calcutta Port must become a very busy port. Since this is a river port, some deep water sea ports must also be found.

And add Sound Money to the list - for the same news report quoted above talks about Mamata Banerjee's "rice for 2 rupees a kg" scheme for the poor in Jangalmahal: the area where Maoism / Naxalism is rife. This may be necessary now, for where there is no peace there can be no market. Peace is another prescription for Bengal - if she wants Capitalism.  But so long as this cheap rice is paid for by printed paper rupees, it makes no sense - for the cost of everything else rises: inflation.

Thus, the poriborton that Bengal needs is just this: 

Communism must be replaced by Capitalism.

No more a "nation of baboos."

From now on, let Bengal be a Nation of Shopkeepers!


PS: Part 2 of this post can be read here.

Monday, January 10, 2011

The Protection Of Life


The "armed cadre" of the Communist Party (CPI-M) gunned down eight villagers in Bengal yesterday. Killings have been going on every day for months now - and reports say that the main opposition party, Trinamool Congress, is in league with the armed Maoists.

Two questions emerge: first, how do ordinary citizens protect their lives; and second, what do we do with the State Police. Let us discuss the police first, since in India, the protection of life is a State monopoly: the State Police have all the guns, while the citizens are completely disarmed. Ten "terrorists" killed 200 people in Mumbai over two whole days a few years back - and all that some brave citizens could do was throw stones at them.

In Bengal, the "armed cadres" of the CPI-M and the Maoists are a fact of life. As is the fact that the State Police, in addition, are also under the command-and-control of the ruling CPI-M. As to what ought to be done to protect ordinary lives, I found the ToI editorial of today extremely naive. The editors say:

The way is clear. Terminate the political succour that permit militias to spawn and become a law unto themselves, and permit the police to function without let or hindrance against militias of whatever political stripe. If state police cannot tackle the job by themselves, Bhattacharjee ought to take this up with the Union home minister and call for central paramilitary reinforcements.

Let us not forget that there is much talk of "saffron terror" nowadays; and that the State Police in Gujarat are quite saffron themselves. How can you "de-politicise" a State Police? Swaminathan Aiyar made the same naive proposal the other day - and none were convinced. When we see that State education is politicised, the IAS is politicised, the judiciary is politicised - how can we possibly expect the State Police to be apolitical? If they were indeed apolitical, why would they be spending most of their efforts protecting VVIPs and VIPs - while neglecting everyone else? How come over 200,000 pedestrians and cyclists die on our unsafe roads every year?

My own horrible experience with the Karnataka State Police during my time in Mangalore confirms that they are the very opposite of what "rule of law" means. The term, which originated in feudal England, means that the King and his men are also "under the law"; that the King and his men cannot engage in "lawless" deeds - like murder. This is something we orientals have never been able to demand of our rulers: The Emperor Akbar, for example, could execute anyone he chose to, in whatever way he liked.

Early on during my stay in Mangalore, the State Police shot and killed two women in the nearby hills, accusing them of being "Naxalites." There were huge protests from civil society - schools, colleges, students, teachers and professors.

This is not "rule of law" - which means prosecution and conviction in a court of law. These are simply "extra-judicial killings" or "encounter deaths" - and are extremely common nowadays.

When I toured the affected area, I was harassed, arrested repeatedly on flimsy charges, or no charges, and on one occasion goons were sent to my hotel room to liquidate me. When I formally complained to the Lokayukta (ombudsman), I found that the officer receiving my complaint was a policeman! The Karnataka Lokayukta is just an extension of the State Police. Small wonder then that I received no justice.

Thus, as I have repeatedly said, the "rule of law" does not exist in India. The State Police are as "lawless" as any party militia. Veerappan was murdered - without any recourse to the "due process" of law. Indeed, the entire criminal justice system is a flop show; a huge disgrace. Investigation, detection, prosecution, courts - nothing works.

So how does the citizen protect his or her life? My own view is that it would be best if our stringent gun control legislation was considerably relaxed. We need the "right to keep and bear arms." We must be able to protect our own lives and properties when The State fails in this task - which it has monopolised. In support of my position, here is an extract from the Report of the National Police Commission - the report from the mid-1970s that was never ever tabled in Parliament. In the section "Looking Ahead" the report calls for "Self Policing":

Of the answers to the problems that are developing the most important is self-policing. Self-policing means (1) taking adequate preventive measures to protect life and property; (2) resisting an attempt on life and/or property, should it take place in spite of preventive measures undertaken in exercising the right of private defence, and (3) active involvement in the processes of the criminal justice system.


There are armed lawless men roaming free almost all over India. Country-made guns are widely available and cheap. Getting a gun license is next to impossible - and legal guns cost a bomb, while legal ammunition is of poor quality. I think it is time we in India think of private solutions to security. Swaminathan Aiyar's idea of "freeing the police from political control" - a view echoed by the ToI editorial of today - is yet another example of looking towards our The State for a solution to our problems. This line of approach cannot work. It is time we realised that our The State is The Problem. All solutions are "private."

Remember: A gun in the hand is better than a cop on the phone.

A gun is a consumer durable that serves to make the consumer more durable.

If you want to support gun rights in India, sign in here.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Secession - A "Crime" Or A "Right"?


Arundhati Roy is in the news these days because of a speech she made supporting the Kashmiri people in their battle against the central State. Apparently, the Delhi Police were about to register a case against her for the "crime of sedition." Most commentators have appealed to the "right to free speech" in order to defend Roy. In this post, I seek to go further, and uphold the right of any people to secede from any State that they do not wish to be part of.

Let us begin with the basic theory of "political organisation" - which in modern times is the Hobbesian "nation-state," run on the principles of "liberal democracy." The most important aspect of this State is that the people are governed not by force, but by consent. In the case of Kashmir, or Manipur, or the areas now under the sway of Naxals and Maoists, it is obvious that "consent" has been entirely lost, and all that is being applied is "force." This is quite like the despots of yore, of whom Mises writes, in Liberalism: The Classical Tradition (pdf here):

As long as nations were ruled by monarchical despots, the idea of adjusting the boundaries of the state to coincide with the boundaries between nationalities could not find acceptance. If a potentate desired to incorporate a province into his realm, he cared little whether the inhabitants—the subjects—agreed to a change of rulers or not. The only consideration that was regarded as relevant was whether the available military forces were sufficient to conquer and hold the territory in question. One justified one's conduct publicly by the more or less artificial construction of a legal claim. The nationality of the inhabitants of the area concerned was not taken into account at all.

Alexander the Great, Julius Caesar, and the Socialist Indian State - all believe in this theory. These ideas were finally destroyed by the great classical liberal political philosophers of the 18th and early 19th centuries. As Ludwig von Mises explained the liberal ideal:

The goal of the domestic policy of liberalism is the same as that of its foreign policy: peace. It aims at peaceful cooperation just as much between nations as within each nation. The starting point of liberal thought is the recognition of the value and importance of human cooperation, and the whole policy and program of liberalism is designed to serve the purpose of maintaining the existing state of mutual cooperation among the members of the human race and of extending it still further. The ultimate ideal envisioned by liberalism is the perfect cooperation of all mankind, taking place peacefully and without friction.

This is the "international division of labour" the liberals of yore thought would be accomplished through peaceful and free international trade.

Therefore, since the essential liberal ideas are those of peace and trade between and among peoples, of Property and Liberty, with only "negative duties" for the State, it made no sense to expand territory while endangering the vital peace. After all, Property is all Private. And the idea is not that The State creates wealth, but people do - so the fatal idea of "territory" did not appeal to them at all. They did not want a State that sought "acres and revenues." The classical liberals did not believe in territory as a "collective property." Thus we see Adam Smith strongly supporting the American demand for secession. He also opposed the colonisation of India.

Following this great tradition, Mises stood for the right to secede as an essential aspect of the "right to self-determination." He wrote thus, in 1927:

The right of self-determination in regard to the question of membership in a state thus means: whenever the inhabitants of a particular territory, whether it be a single village, a whole district, or a series of adjacent districts, make it known, by a freely conducted plebiscite, that they no longer wish to remain united to the state to which they belong at the time, but wish either to form an independent state or to attach themselves to some other state, their wishes are to be respected and complied with. This is the only feasible and effective way of preventing revolutions and civil and international wars.


Remember: the goal is peace and peaceful co-operation and trade. Territory is immaterial.

Mises then added a qualification:

To call this right of self-determination the "right of self-determination of nations" is to misunderstand it. It is not the right of self-determination of a delimited national unit, but the right of the inhabitants of every territory to decide on the state to which they wish to belong.

Unfortunately, the 20th century did not see these liberal ideas victorious. This was when the planet and its peoples were divided into "nation-states," each nation behind its own tariff walls, and each operating a "national economy." This is the only reason why this century was a century of great wars engulfing the whole world. Total wars. These wars continue because of these very same stupid ideas. The only cure: Libertarianism, the direct descendant of classical liberalism.

With modern "liberal democracy" - which is essentially Hobbesian - there has come about a new kind if illiberal doctrine regarding the "right to secede." According to this doctrine, the liberal democratic nation-state is "perfectly just" because it provides each citizen with "human rights" and further dispenses to him "social justice." This adds Rousseau's "Social Contract" to Hobbes. The theory of justice is the one propounded by John Rawls.

Thus, the right to secede has been eliminated - even in America! And Abraham Lincoln is the man responsible.

This is really not "liberal democracy"; rather, it is just democracy shorn of the liberal ideals of old; it is the ritual of voting - without Liberty, without Property, and the added plunder of protectionism. It is basically "socialist," sometimes even "fascistic." It is Legislation; it is bureaucracy. It is the "politicization of economic life." It is nothing but "statism." And as for the "political parties" - I have only just written a post on these gangs of thugs.

But this was never the social theory of the classical liberals, according to which, rather than a monolithic Hobbesian central State monopolising "security," each Individual was pre-possessed of Property as well as the right to defend himself and his property. All that the classical liberals desired is a system of laws by which Life and Property could be better protected. They did not accept the "myth of national defence" and they did not desire any "social justice," nor any "redistribution." Property and Liberty were the only great ideas, then.

(You can read an excellent journal article on the Right to Secession, explaining all these ideas, here.)

In modern India, we have got the whole thing completely wrong - because of wrong ideas. There is no point in upholding "territorial integrity" when vital peace, trade and co-operation are missing. Arundhati Roy has done the right thing by supporting the struggle of the Kashmiri people. This surely cannot be a "crime."

My ideal is a world of independent, self-governing and free-trading cities and towns. Peace, Trade, Property, Liberty, Civilisation. Thus, there is no need for a Kashmiri "nation state." Rather, Srinagar, Jammu and Leh should have independent local governments running the cities, ditto for all the towns. I believe that this approach, entirely consistent with the principles of classical liberalism, is the only solution to the crisis of political organisation that faces the people of India today.

Friday, August 20, 2010

On The Right To Keep And Bear Arms


Here are some questions that all honest, tax-paying, law-abiding citizens of India must ask themselves:

1. Should we blindly trust The State?
2. Should we blindly trust the State Police to look after us and protect us?

If the answer to these questions is a loud "No," then we must face up to the fact that, in India, we are faced with the peculiar situation that they have all the guns, and we have been systematically unarmed.

We are defenceless.

They have all the guns.

And, to top it all, the Central State Police Ministry is seriously attempting to make gun ownership even more difficult for us.

The new arms policy requires a citizen to prove grave and imminent threat to life prior to the grant of arms license.

Think about it: The criminal, the terrorist, the Maoist - they do not require gun licenses at all. They simply buy illegal guns in the black market and use them. There are numberless factories in India that produce crude guns - and these are quite popular, and cheap.

But if a regular citizen wants a regular gun, the procedures make it impossible; there is a huge amount of corruption; and these legal guns and the ammunition required are horrendously expensive.

Ten terrorists killed hundreds in Mumbai recently - because the citizenry has been unarmed.

The State Police could do nothing to prevent this two-day slaughter.

How can we protect ourselves?

For quite a few years now, I have been a member of Indians For Guns. This group, led by Abhijeet Singh, champions our right to keep and bear arms. I am in full support of their endeavours. You can visit their website here; their Facebook page here.

"A gun in the hand is better than a cop on the phone" is a saying I strongly believe in. In the field of personal security, as in all other fields, I strongly believe in self-help. I believe in private security; I believe in private guns.

Today, there is some good news for people like me: A group of MPs from many parties, led by Digvijay Singh, former Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh, a veteran CONgressman who has been in the news for strongly criticizing the State Police in their handling of the Naxalites and Maoists, has called upon the Prime Minister and opposed the new arms policy being touted by the Central Police Ministry. Read the news report here. This is a most welcome development. The report mentions that Digvijay Singh is the patron-in-chief of the National Association for Gun Rights, India. Finally, we seem to have some "good politics." By good politics I mean a politics that is for the citizenry, and against the powers and privileges of the State and the State Police. Our current Central Police Minister, P Chidambaram, plays politics of the opposite sort. Chidambaram seems to be in the pockets of the "security establishment."

There is one part of India where all the citizens have the right to keep and bear arms, and that is Coorg, in Karnataka. I visited this district and lectured far and wide. One of the colleges presented me with their emblem: Two crossed machetes with a rifle going through them! It is noteworthy that there is complete peace in Coorg. No terrorism. No Naxalites. And no police atrocities either.

As an economist, I would like to add that our State Police today are nothing but an ugly MONOPOLY. Further, the political theory that the State Police monopoly should be our only provider of security is nothing but COMMUNISM. Free societies cannot be thus. And Indyeah must aim to be a free society.

The first economist in the world to say this was Gustave de Molinari in France during the 19th century. Molinari was a close associate of Frederic Bastiat and the editor-in-chief of their Journal des Economistes. His brief essay on the "Production of Security" - with a foreword by Murray Rothbard - can be found here. It is well worth a read in these troubled times, in this troubled country - a country in which the State Police are largely seen as predators, not protectors. I strongly recommend this essay to readers of my blog.

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Horrifying!

I find it particularly horrifying that the Total Chacha State has decided to use the Army and the Air Force to tackle the Maoists in the jungles of Central India. Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi wants to "enforce the writ of the State."

In the meantime, the historian Ramachandra Guha has penned a thoughtful column on the ongoing crisis in Manipur, wherein he concludes that the best thing that can be done is to repeal the Armed Forces Special Powers Act. This Act, by which the Army has called the shots in Manipur, has been in force since the 50s, since before I was born. And there has never been any peace. Indeed, if anything, the "writ of the State" was never to be found on the ground. It is this scenario that our Total Chacha State wants to repeat in Central India. They want to thrive on chaos. They want never-ending civil wars all over India so that the sheeple have no other choice but to look towards them for a solution. This nefarious plan of theirs must be defeated.

Democracy means self-government. It means Liberty. It means the diffusion of power, not its centralization. It means politics solves conflicts, not bullets. The implications for the Maoists are threefold: the tribals must enjoy their rights to Private Property and free exchange; they must "self-police" their homelands; and the Maoist ideology must be tackled politically - which is impossible because liberalism is debarred entry into Indian politics.

Let us not forget that Chacha is a central planner. He overestimates the ability of the State's powers of compulsion and coercion in economic affairs. He therefore proceeds naturally to overestimating the ability of the armed forces to solve a mass uprising. We need a mass politician to do that. Not Chacha. He is taking us headlong into disaster.

Horrifying!

Sunday, May 30, 2010

Cops Are "Civilians": Take # 2

The Barkha Dutt Show last night was on Maoism, and featured a very senior IPS officer with a huge handlebar moustache; a very "military" mien. During the show, this dude said something so stupid and wrong that I decided to comment on it today, to be read along with yesterday's post. The IPS officer said that policemen are like soldiers in the armed forces, because they too wear a uniform. Barkha too kept referring to constables of the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) as "soldiers."

Nothing could be further from the truth. Policemen are "civilians" and this IPS officer was himself recruited through a "Civil Services Examination."

Indeed, what has gone wrong with policing in India is that it is increasingly becoming a "military police." This is just another sordid aspect of socialist totalitarianism. The Central State has over 200 battalions of the CRPF under its command and control, and they are used at will to supercede the local police. This is a development in our polity that should be a cause for great worry.

We in India, because of State Socialism, have lost the essence of "civil government." Our politicians are all "party animals" who never earn their keep in The Market. They just live off the fat of the land. Our "civil servants" are all party workers too - and this means that our government is a "party government" - of the socialist party or parties. The very word "civilian," in India, does not apply to any government functionary.

It was the Honourable East India Company that brought civil government to India. There were three "services" to which a recruit could belong - the civil service, the military service, and the opium service. The lowest rung of their civil service was that of "writer," and he was known as a "civilian" - to differentiate him from the military man. There was no separate police service till 1861, by which time the administration of India had been passed on to the Crown. But the Imperial Police was still civilian. George Orwell worked for this branch of the government - in Burma. The officers of the Imperial Police would have been aghast had anyone considered them at par with the military.

When India first got its police forces in 1861, the idea was still quite new in Britain itself. Robert Peel had created the London Metropolitan Police a few decades earlier - the "Bobby" is named after him - and it is unthinkable that these unarmed constables could be likened to recruits to the British Army. They were, and still are, civilians.

The very fact that a senior IPS officer, on prime-time television, could call his office "military," and the added fact that the CRPF "military police" are seen as the solution to our law and order problems, illustrates how horrible our "civil administration" has become. Especially the police.

In yesterday's post I had outlined my solution to Maoism: Withdraw the State Police from all tribal areas. Let the tribals "self-police." For a long-term solution to our problems, I suggest DRASTIC police reforms. We don't need a military police. We certainly don't need a politicized State police. At worst, let us have local constabulary under the control of city and town mayors, to perform duties of riot control only, where necessary. Nothing more.

For more on my views on criminal justice, see the relevant chapter in my Natural Order: Essays Exploring Civil Government & The Rule of Law, free e-book here.

Saturday, May 29, 2010

Crises Are Good For Them, Barkha

Barkha Dutt of NDTV has written an article on the latest Maoist outrage - derailing a train in Bengal, causing over 100 deaths - that advocates strong State action to neutralize the Maoists. To quote:

Like in any conflict zone — with the Maoists too— we seek a deft combination of battle strategy and smart politics operating on parallel tracks. When we see civilians under attack or poor jawans forced to be at the frontline of danger, we certainly expect our government to use force — both preventive and offensive — against brutal, senseless terror. Whether this force takes the shape of the paramilitary or the army; whether air support should be deployed to speed up the ferrying of troops and weapons — we may leave to the strategists.

Note the royal "we."

My friends at the Natural Order Blog have a thought for today that all of us should ponder over:

“Fear of disorder and love of well-being unconsciously lead democracies to increase the functions of the central government,” said Alexis-Charles-Henri Clérel de Tocqueville in a warning that should be heeded by all freedom-loving people.


Barkha Dutt's column is titled "Call a spade a spade." She wants to call the Maoists a spade. What about the Total Chacha State? Shouldn't we call the King of Spades a spade too?

In reality, such crises are great for the King of Spades and his minions in North Block - the "strategists" Dutt refers to. I recall a senior IPS officer from Assam telling me, in the early 1980s, that "law and order problems are good for us." He added that "we get more powers, more personnel, more jeeps and more wireless sets." Barkha laments the fact that poor jawans die on the field - but these senior strategists in North Block just shuffle files and make hay.

If I may pen my sincere thoughts on a "solution" to Maoism, then it is this: Get the State Police to entirely withdraw from any involvement in tribal affairs. I briefly served as District Superintendent of Police in Arunachal Pradesh in 1987 - and the great thing there is that I had powers only in the towns. The hinterland was beyond my control - and the tribals lived happily in their "natural order." That is why there is still peace in Arunachal Pradesh. This should be the model for all forested areas inhabited by tribals. Give them full powers over their lives and properties. Give them Liberty and Property Under Law. And then tackle the "ideology" of Maoism politically.

What will happen if the Maoists "take control"? (Actually, they are already in control.) They will then have no "enemy" to fight. They will have to govern under Law. With the right politics educating the tribals on their rights and liberties, the natural order will be speedily restored. Of course, this will require The Market - a social institution that no political party in India says anything in favour of.

Monday, May 17, 2010

Against The State Police

The Maoists have struck once again and blown up a bus. Some "special police officers" (read "informers") were the specific target, but some 50 people have died. On the idiot box last night, I watched the Central State Police ministry's secretary lament the "loss of innocent civilian lives." This is humbug.

In India, the innocent civilian is always the target of police brutality. He is harassed at every turn. He hates the police. In these Maoist badlands, it is police atrocities upon "innocent civilians" that have turned the average tribal into an armed guerrilla. It must never be forgotten that in West Bengal the rebel organization is called People's Committee Against Police Atrocities (PCPA).

In this news report, the Central State Police Minister is quoted asking for the intellectual support of independent journalists and civil society groups. This should be denied him. In the same report he talks of using "air support" against the Maoists. Wow! We now have an internal civil war going on. Same in Kashmir. Same in the north-east.

All these internal problems require "politics" to solve them. Tax-funded rifles, grenades, bullets, drones and air support can accomplish nothing - except to turn this malfunctioning socialist democracy into a Total Police State. This is in the vested interest of the top brass of the State Police - the denizens of North Block. For them, persistent law and order problems means bigger budgets and more powers. They must be defeated.

What I would like to ask the Central State Police Minister is this: Does he think the State Police are liked and respected anywhere in India?

On the streets, ordinary innocent civilians actually hate and despise the police.

We need drastic police reform. We need to defang the police by making all voluntary trades legit. We do not need to take the opposite direction - which the Police Minister is urging upon us. No independent journalist, no civil society group, should come out in favour of the police.

Actually, why only the police? What about our politicians? Does anyone in the entire territory of India like a single politician?

Much fuss is being made now about the hanging of Afzal Guru, the mastermind of the (unsuccessful) armed attack on Parliament some years ago. I remember that day. I was then on the editorial team of a major business daily. At the morning edit meeting, I asked my colleagues what they thought about the attack. One guy replied: "They should have got at least a few MPs." He was quite serious, I do believe. It was I who was surprised to see how much our MPs are hated.

These are dangerous times. One wrong move and we could end up with Police Totalitarianism. The National Intelligence Grid, the biometrci ID card project, the caste census - these are all steps in the direction of totalitarianism.

You are warned.

Saturday, May 15, 2010

Kishenji Is A Nehruvian Socialist

The Maoist supremo, Kishenji, has called for a 48-hour "bandh" in 5 states - Bihar, West Bengal, Jharkhand, Orissa and Chhattisgarh. A bandh is a shutdown of all economic activity and all markets - a general strike. It is not voluntary. Force is invariably misused to shut all businesses down.

What is generally overlooked is that bandhs are terrible for the poor, especially daily-wage earners. On bandh day they cannot sell their labour, nor can they procure their needs. Kishenji is flexing political muscle. But he is not helping the poor.

All political parties in India employ bandhs - especially the CPI(M), whom the Maoists hate. Thus, Kishenji's political tactics are indistinguishable from the mainstream socialist and communist parties.

But it gets worse.

Why is Kishenji calling for a bandh?

Answer: "To protest against the Centre's decision to sell ten percent government's stake in 10 profit-making Public Sector Undertakings."

Read the full report here.

What have PSUs got to do with the welfare of tribals? We have had PSUs for over 60 years and the conditions of our tribals has only worsened.

Kishenji has some other demands:

=> Shut down IPL

=> Throw out foreign banks

Does cricket matter to tribals?

Won't tribals benefit from foreign Capital?

So what is Kishenji, I ask?

It seems to me that he is a confirmed Nehruvian socialist. With his political ideals, he would be welcome in Parliament. He is just like any other pig from that pigsty. He probably studied in JNU - or Presidency College. I wonder which.

Anyway, I hope some tribals somewhere will read my solution to their problems - Liberty.

And I recommend a re-read of an earlier post on the Maoist vs Nehruvian phony war.

Sad, but true: We are faced with MORONS on all sides - in the State and out of it.

The fault lies in State education - which creates these uniform mindsets.

Homeschool your children. Save their minds.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

The Cart... And The Horse

There is an interesting video I have for you today, of the Central State Police Minister, speaking to CII - the cronies of the Total Chacha State - on how their help is needed to "develop" the forested and mineral-rich tribal areas of Central India now dominated by armed Maoist rebels. The minister starts off asking: "How can we take development to these areas?" He then confesses that the "government development model has not been successful" and he asks his cronies of they can provide "another delivery mechanism."

The minister is nuts. He is putting the cart before the horse. Development can never occur through either State or corporate handouts. There is no "delivery mechanism" required.

Rather, The Market is about "production and exchange." Production comes first. These people must be free to produce for the market, and then be free to exchange their produce for procuring their needs. This is how the horse comes before the cart.

What do these people produce?

First and foremost, they produce an excellent alcoholic drink called mahua, named after a jungle flower from which it is distilled. This is illegal today. This ban must be immediately lifted and mahua plantations encouraged in the jungles. This mahua must be freely sold throughout India, and it should be seen as the patriotic duty of all Indians to patronize this drink.

Second: every tribal household is able to produce a rice beer called handia. For this too I prescribe Liberty.

Thirdly: In many of these jungle areas, especially in Orissa and Andhra Pradesh, the tribals are growing ganja. This must be legalized too.

Fourthly: These areas are rich in minerals. These minerals do not belong to the Central State; they belong to these tribals. Private Property must be respected in law. Let all the royalties from mining go to these tribal communities. Let their local governments be fully empowered to allow (or disallow) mining. There is an interesting interview with Bianca Jagger in today's ToI where she speaks of tribal exploitation by mining giants in cohorts with the Central State. This must stop.

Lastly: As with minerals, so too with forests and wildlife - these belong to the tribals and they must be free to utilize them for their own benefit. They must be free to grow and sell timber. They must be free to farm and sell wildlife products - like venison. Our 5-star hotels should serve venison steaks with mahua to wash them down - and we will soon find these very people buying cars, computers and whatever else the cronies of CII produce.

This is how we put the horse before the cart.

These very questions plagued the British parliament in the 18th century, when the debate over free trade for Ireland arose. Ireland was then the poorest province of Europe. People were starving. And the British government denied them the freedom to trade. As public anger mounted, and volunteers were armed to resist the State, the government asked many eminent people for their opinion on what should be done, among them Adam Smith, whose Wealth of Nations had just been published - and hugely praised.

Adam Smith called for free trade for Ireland, even though it would hurt English and Scottish monopolies. He rallied against these "most absurd monopolies that we have most absurdly instituted against ourselves." He placed the cart before the horse. He saw that if the Irish sell their produce, they will accumulate Capital, and they will increase their consumption. They will survive. Public anger would recede. The Irish would focus on production and exchange, instead of spending their energies and their lives on insurrection.

To paraphrase Smith, we could today, in India, on the question of the Maoists, speak of the "most absurd RESTRICTIONS we have most absurdly imposed upon ourselves - and also upon these tribals." Liberty is the answer. All these absurd restrictions must go.

Further, Private Property must be the Law.

To conclude: I once met an Englishman at a rock concert in New Delhi who had arrived there after a stint in Kabul, where he had gone as a humanitarian volunteer. When asked about conditions in Kabul he told me:

Where there is no economy, what can a young man do but pick up a gun and join one predatory gang or another?


This is the situation in our tribal heartlands. There is no economy. The minister himself admits that the government model of development has failed. They put the cart before the horse. Government action can NEVER lead to development - but it can thwart it, and it has. The answer is to get The Market working - by giving these people the Liberty to produce and exchange.

There is no other solution.

Recommended read: My earlier post on Adam Smith on the Irish question.

Friday, April 30, 2010

On ID Cards, Unions, And The Chacha GUNvernment

I have a fair bit of fare for you today - biometric ID cards, Labour Day, and the CONgress theory of GUNvernment - so let's begin with the ID card. Yesterday, I had rubbished the very idea itself, as based on the Welfare Principle. I had omitted mentioning anything that might be "Orwellian" in the idea. Well, today there is an excellent column in the Express on the very Orwellian possibilities behind the biometric ID card project. That is, the idea is being promoted as welfarism, but actually smacks of totalitarianism. Nandan Nilekani may well be an agent of the Police State, with Chacha as his sponsor. Oppose the evil idea of biometric ID cards tooth-and-nail.

On now to Labour Day. Independent India was conceived of as a workers' paradise, but even today masses are poor, and many are in armed rebellion against it. What went wrong? Obviously, socialism and trade unionism are NOT in the interests of the working classes.

Do not forget that all workers are consumers - while labour, strictly speaking, is a "disutility." We work in order to spend our wages on satisfying our needs. Thus free trade and free competition are in the workers' interests - and this was the clear understanding among the working people in Cobden's time, when the English working people unitedly rose in opposition to protectionism and mercantilistic privileges. Sadly, 50 years later, they succumbed to the lures of socialism and trade unionism. And see what great disaster has befallen them. There ain't no cure but classical liberalism.

The unhampered free market - or Capitalism - is the BEST for ALL workers. Trade unions are a privileged elite. They are also allowed to use force legally. This goes against the Principle of Justice. Nobel Laureate F.A. Hayek once said, "We have now reached a state where [unions] have become uniquely privileged institutions to which the general rules of law do not apply." Students are also recommended the works of the late Professor WH Hutt, a staunch classical liberal, who clearly saw through the evil of unionism.

Not just Britain or India, the USSA too has got fucked by trade unionism. Detroit is a dead city today. LRC has a great column on trade unionism in the USSA by Tom Woods that is truly worth reading. It shows that India must break free from this great error in our social system - that too, in the true interests of poor workers. I hate trade unions in the West for another reason: they are the biggest supporters of immigration control. If you want a free, competitive world for all workers, you must oppose unionism.

Finally, there is this NYT story titled "India's ruling party's biggest challenge remains governing" that I found worthy of note. Hah! Governing? What does Chacha know about that? Their entire theory of the Total State is based on force, force and more force - and always the misuse of force. The biometric ID card, the trade union, the State Police, the Income Tax "raid," and so on and so forth, right down to the bloody excise bastards. This is a theory of GUNvernment, not government. It is good that people are finally rebelling. More power to the rebels.

Thursday, April 22, 2010

The Crisis... And The News

For the past two days I have been bored stiff by both newspaper and television headlining the political scandal in commercial cricket. Surely, there are more pressing issues in the news, from Maoism to the Finance Bill.

On Maoism, Barun Mitra's WSJ column to which I referred to yesterday has been published by Mint today, here. The title: "Pull the land issue from under the Maoists." Precisely! But that means we need a State that upholds and protects Private Property - which is a Capitalist State. Further, that means the Adivasis should be seen as "good guys" fighting for their Property, and the current establishment, including their State Police, as the "bad buys," hell-bent on usurping Property. That is, as I had earlier said:

This is a Crisis of Legitimacy.


However, the newspapers and television are all worked up about a total non-issue: the scandal at IPL. There are many "socialist pigs" calling for the nationalization of IPL. What is even worse is that the Income Tax Department has been conducting "raids" on IPL offices, in a manner reminiscent of those totalitarian times when socialist pigs ruled the roost.

Perhaps the ruse in the media spin is to portray the private sector as corrupt. This should not be allowed to succeed. Politicians get "free equity" because they, and not the private player, are corrupt.

Further, the Income Tax Department is worse than the State Police, who at least perform some useful functions. The IT Deptt. is but a band of tax parasites. In a kleptocracy, there is little point paying taxes. All these taxes the IT Deptt. steals from us are our Capital that goes into the Total Chacha State's "consumption": precious Capital is destroyed. And there is more.

As Ludwig von Mises always pointed out, "progressive taxation" of the kind the IT Deptt. imposes go against the interests of poor workers. If Capital is not taxed, then it gets invested, and workers' wages rise. Chacha is screwing the poor with this parasitical IT Deptt. They should be seen as less legitimate than even the State Police.

There are three aspects to the science of Economics:

Economic theory
Economic policy
Public finance


And Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi gets a "zero" on all three.

And he faces a crisis of legitimacy.

That should be the news.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

For A "My Piece Of Earth Day"

My last post said it all: This is a constitutional crisis. This is a crisis for socialist public administration. This is a crisis for socialist jurisprudence.

The future of India belongs to Private Property.

There is no other solution to Maoist/Naxalite insurgency.

No longer must The State own everything while The People own nothing.

From now on The People must own everything while The State merely administers their affairs - a Private Property Natural Order. Also called Capitalism. This is also the "political" solution to Maoism, an ideology based on "collective property."

Today, I am glad to report that I have Barun Mitra on my side, writing in the Wall Street Journal that securing private property rights in the jungles is the only way to beat the Maoists. He talks about the Forest Rights Act, 2007; how this Act is not being implemented; and how it has seen "vociferous opposition from various environmentalists."

These environmentalists must also be seen as an enemy. Their God is the forest guard. They hate the idea of tribal people as proprietors of their forests.

Their great day is approaching: Earth Day.

I suggest an alternative day for all tribals:

My Piece Of The Earth Day.


That's right! Private property in forests and wildlife - and minerals.

The Natural Order Blog has an excellent post on the foolish ideas of modern environmentalists, who are invariably statists. They do not want The People to look after their immediate environment. Rather, they want The State to perform this function. Actually, as recent history shows, the more powerful the State - as in the USSR, China and India - the worse the environment.

So do read the post.

And watch out for these stupid environmentalists and their silly sentimentality over "nature."

The Private Property Order is also "nature" - based on the Nature of Man.

Capitalism (and cities) are Man's "natural environment."

So say "No" to Earth Day.

And let's have a "My Piece Of The Earth Day."

Cheers!

Sunday, April 18, 2010

A Constitutional Crisis

A retired IAS officer, BS Raghavan, formerly chief secretary to the government of West Bengal, has written a column on a "much simpler solution to Maoism," wherein he looks the problem in the eye. He writes:

I am obliged to Deboo Bandyopadhyay, than whom it is difficult to find a person who has made such a deep study of Naxalism, for the information that, according to a knowledgeable scholar, Dr Walter Fernandes, between 1947 and 2004 nearly six crore (60 million) persons were forcibly displaced due to acquisition of land for development purposes, and of them 40 per cent constituted Scheduled Tribes. Out of a total population of generic tribals of eight crore, 2.4 crore (24 million) were involuntarily thrown out of their land, home and occupation. This figure constitutes 30 per cent of the total tribal population.

Official figures admit that only 28 per cent of the displaced tribal population has been rehabilited. Assuming that even this low figure is not an exaggeration, what happened to the remaining 72 per cent of the displaced tribals numbering 1.44 crore (14.4 million)?


We must all thank Deboo for giving his highness this information, which surely should have been at the fingertips of a socialist planning bureaucracy equipped with so much statistics.

But does this retired IAS officer see Private Property as a Principle that needs to be upheld by the civilian administration? No. He has a "simpler solution":

There is a much simpler answer to Maoism than even development, and that is good and honest governance and rule of law. There should be visible evidence that the government is determined to deal summary justice to the corrupt and the venal, rid legislatures and cabinets of persons involved in crimes, and inculcate sensitivity, empathy, responsiveness, commitment to values, dedication to the public weal and, most of all, humility in public servants from top to bottom.


Note that these are just pretty words, devoid of any understanding of the First Principle of Government.

In his posthumously published pamphlet, Interventionism: An Economic Analyisis (Pdf here, go to page 8 of the text for the following quote) Ludwig von Mises writes of what The State is expected to do in a Capitalist Society, which should be the direction in which most of us want to proceed, finding nothing attractive in either socialism or Maoism - or even Hindootva. It must be Capitalism Or Bust, which means a Private Property Order. Mises writes these important words about what The State is expected to do in such an order, something which should be of great interest to those who administer our public affairs. Mises writes:

In a market economy the State concerns itself with the protection of the life, health, and private property of its citizens against force or fraud. The state insures the smooth working of the market economy by the weight of its coercive power. It refrains, however, from any interference with the freedom of action of the people engaged in production and distribution so long as such actions do not involve the use of force or fraud against the life, health, safety, or property of others. This very fact characterizes such a community as a market economy or a capitalist economy.

If liberal, i.e., classical liberals, oppose governmental interference in the economic sphere they do so because they feel certain that the market economy is the only efficient and workable system of social cooperation. They are convinced that no other system would be in a position to bring more welfare and happiness to the people.

The English and French liberals and the fathers of the U.S. Constitution insisted upon the protection of private property, not to further the selfish interests of one class, but rather for the protection of the whole people and because they saw the welfare of the nation and of each individual most secure in the system of a market economy.

It is, therefore, naive to say that the true liberal advocates of private property are enemies of the state because they want to see the realm of governmental activity limited. They are not enemies of the state but opponents of both socialism and interventionism because they believe in the superior efficacy of the market economy. They want a strong and well-administered state because they assign to it an important task: the protection of the system of a market economy.

Even more naive were the Prussian metaphysicians when they maintained that the program of the adherents of a market economy was negative. To these supporters of Prussian totalitarianism everything seemed negative that stood in the way of their desire to create more governmental jobs. The program of the advocates of a market economy is negative only in the sense in which every program is negative: It excludes all other programs. Because the true liberals are positively for private ownership of the means of production and for a market economy they are necessarily against socialism and interventionism.


IAS men are like the "Prussian metaphysicians." They don't know First Principles. I had earlier written about the IAS Academy director Wajahat Habibullah, currenctly "misinformation czar," and his "misteaching" of young recruits. This should be seen as a crisis in socialist public administration.

What this means is that, if we want Capitalism, and we want the "Rule of Law" and "good governance" and all those pretty words this retired highness dreamt up, we need to stress Private Property as the First Principle.

This should be seen as a Constitutional Crisis - because the socialist constitution does NOT recognize Private Property at all.

A crisis of legitimacy.

Saturday, April 17, 2010

Chacha Is "The Gravest Threat"

For the past few days I have been writing about the Maoists, suggesting the simple solution of Private Property - which is Justice. Only when there is no Justice does "power flow through the barrel of a gun" - as Chairman Mao famously said.

Today, I would like to reiterate a point I made weeks back, when the Union Budget was presented in Parliament. I then called it "The Monster's Budget" and advised the citizenry to ask their representatives to vote against the Finance Bill, so as to "Bring Chacha Down."

Yes, in my opinion, it is not the Maoists, but Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi, who is "India's gravest security threat." It was laughable seeing Chacha and Obama at the "Nuclear Security Summit" the other day, when both are busy making the lives of the people they govern financially insecure.

Indeed, as an economist, I do believe that financial security comes uppermost. If you have the Capital, you can make yourself quite secure. You can buy guns, engage security guards from The Market, buy insurance - and what not. But if you are financially insecure, you are at the mercy of the elements. No "nuclear security" can help you.

My point is this: Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi is NOT an "economist." Real economists believe in "economization." Chacha does not. Rather, he believes in "capital consumption" - as does his friend Obama. Chacha is consuming Capital with all his foolish ideas, from NREGA to "food security" to the "right to free and compulsory (mis)education."

All "welfare" involves capital consumption, because all welfare is about consumption, and not production. Chacha and Obama sail in the same boat - the Pirate Ship of State.

While the Americans have enough to survive on, so they can withstand Obama, we in India have precious little, and cannot survive the onslaught of capital consumption that Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi has unleashed. This "maleconomist" must be brought down from the "commanding heights."

Our economy can only grow if Capital is saved and invested. Further, if foreign Capital is also free to enter. The more Capital we have per unit of Labour, the higher will be the wages of our poor workers. If, on the other hand, precious Capital is consumed on welfare, and foreign Capital is denied entry, our people will always remain poor.

In my post, "The Monster's Budget," I had commented on Chacha's huge borrowing programme. I had shown how those who purchase government bonds are but clients of The State, who receive "interest" from the tax kitty - which adds to capital consumption.

We suffer from double-digit inflation now - and this is also capital consumption.

No siree. We need a balanced budget. No borrowing. Sound money. Private Property. Justice.

We don't need this Uncle Sham "welfare."

Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi must GO!

Chacha is the "gravest threat" to our financial security.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

On Adivasis... And Their Properties

There is news today that the Total Chacha State is testing Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs or "drones") which they plan to use against the poor tribals of Central India. Too funked to fight, eh?

But the fight will go on forever. It will never end.

Here is another report, this time quoting the Army chief, in which this dude says that the Armed Forces Special Powers Act should NOT be diluted in the North-East and Jammu & Kashmir. In Manipur, the AFSPA has been in force since before I was born - and peace is nowhere in sight. Ditto for J&K.

So let us not laud all this "tough talk" about using military might (like UAVs) against the disaffected tribals. They are citizens of India and the only solution must be political. As Jug Suraiya recently put it, "Pehele Aap, Mantriji."

Once again, I repeat the classical liberal line that Private Property is the only solution. Let us consider this extract from the column I referred to in my post of yesterday. The author says:

One positive measure taken in 2006 was the Forest Rights Act. But its implementation leaves a lot to be desired. As of end February 2010, out of the 27 lakh claims filed, 7.6 lakh have been accepted, 9.3 lakh have been rejected and the rest have still to be decided. There are also problems about recognising community rights and the linkages with Joint Forest Management.


The author goes on to make a damning statement:

The rights of the tribals to capture the value of the natural resources in their homelands have never been fully accepted by the rest of us. We displace them in the name of development, compensate them for the loss of their meagre livelihood but fail to accept that they should have a share in the rents that accrue today to mining mafias, forest contractors and corrupt officials.


The word "adivasi" means "original inhabitant." The very word implies that these people have been inhabiting these forests for thousands of generations; indeed, since before the Aryan invasions. It is unthinkable that they should not be possessed of Property in their homelands.

Dunno too much about Mao except that "power flows through the barrel of a gun" - but I know enough about John Locke, who said, in 1691, that "where there is no Property there is no Justice."

It is because there is no Property that power is flowing from the barrel of a gun. The answer is not the UAV; the answer is Settlement Officers who will physically visit the areas and award property titles - just as Munro did in Baramahal. There is no other way. State violence I condemn.

How does a Settlement Officer know who owns what?

One story I read somewhere is that of a Brit who approached a house to check out who owned it, and found a dog barking. He found out who was the dog's master and concluded that the same person must be the owner of the house.

It is as simple as that - if you know something about the science of government.

And if you don't - then there is the UAV, the AFSPA and all that endless blood and gore.

That is the choice before the nation.

History Lessons For Our Adivasis

There is a thoughtful column I found today on the Adivasis, the original inhabitants of the jungles of Central India, who have now turned to Maoism. The author concludes: "What the tribals need is not hand-outs. They need honour and dignity. Give them this and the pool of discontent in which the Maoists swim will dry up."

Honour and dignity are big words. What I had said in an earlier post is that "Private Property Is The Only Solution."

Let us not forget that the white people we love to admire so much today for their modernity, technical know-how, music, art, culture and political institutions were but tribesmen not so long ago. Why did the Anglo-Saxon tribes advance so far ahead of the rest of humanity? Once upon a time, racial superiority was considered to be the only reason, but this explanation is found wanting today when several non-white nations have also advanced - the Japanese, for example. What could be the real reason for the white man's superiority?

The Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto has offered one answer: It was their laws that deserve the credit. These laws were based on the morality of Private Property and, further, these white people developed the system of "property titles" that were "representative" of real Property. Because of these property titles, land could be bought and sold, or mortgaged, and this is how De Soto says the white man solved the "mystery of capital."

There is more, of course, for their laws also protected foreign creditors in their loans. This is how Capitalism kicked in - long before the so-called "industrial revolution." Indeed, the East India Company came to India in the early 1600s - when the industrial revolution was still far away. But Capitalism had arrived in London long ago.

The conclusion: The rapid rise of the Anglo-Saxon tribes has everything to do with their laws, which respected Private Property, and nothing whatsoever to do with race. Thus, our own tribes can progress in precisely the same way, if they adopt the best rules of the game; rules that the Anglo-Saxons accidentally stumbled upon.

Do read the chapter in my Natural Order: Essays Exploring Civil Government & The Rule of Law (free E-book here) where I discuss the "origins of the common law." It is clearly established therein that Private Property is the key. It is therefore highly regrettable that the Adivasis are turning towards Maoism and "collective property" - ideas that will get them nowhere, and ideas that the Total Chacha State cannot fight.

Note that the Founding Fathers of the Republic did not see this. They took the "latest ideas" of the West - socialism, democracy and Keynesianism. They did not look at their ancient heritage. They adopted the worst ideas of the West.

It is also worth noting that it is these modern ideas that are bringing down Western civilization - just as Ludwig von Mises had predicted they would. Since the 1900s, Britain, USA, France, Germany - all these nations have gone the way of socialism and interventionism: what Mises calls the "hampered market economy." These are the very ideas that have brought them down.

There are many great lessons in the history of the West - lessons that backward societies ought to imbibe. If they do so, why the Adivasis, the whole of India could live with "dignity and honour," instead of being considered, by the West, as the world's most poverty-stricken and charity-needing nation.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Beyond The Democratic Pigsty

Yesterday, I said, in agreement with the Maoists, that the Indian parliament is a "pigsty." I rested my case on the government and the opposition being united in pursuing an inflationary policy.

But then again, classical liberals and libertarians are NOT allowed to contest to enter this parliament. The Indian people are free to choose their representatives, yes, but only among officially approved "political parties" - all of whom must swear by the "socialism" in the Constitution. For this reason alone, all classical liberals and libertarians should refer to this parliament as a pigsty - full of "socialist pigs." We must convey to the Maoists that we fully concur with them on their opinion of parliament.

Yet, it is also a fact that parliaments have lost much of their sheen the world-over. The House of Commons was recently rocked by scandal. And as for the USSA, there is this excellent book by PJ O'Rourke (of Rolling Stone magazine and Cato Institute) called Parliament of Whores which I earnestly recommend that you buy and read. Long before Hans-Hermann Hoppe penned his Democracy: The God That Failed, it was PJ O'Rourke who had ripped apart all claims to legitimacy that democracy in the USSA possessed. Yet, I do believe O'Rourke libels all whores, who sell sex based on voluntarism. Parliaments use force. The book would have been better titled Parliament of Rapists.

All over the world, parliaments are busy raping taxpayers and bribing vote banks. All over the world, governments that emerge from these parliaments pursue inflationism. Then there is interventionism. There is protectionism. The voter gets screwed - by force. Raped!

Can we do without these pigsties? I should think so - in direct contradiction to Francis Fukayama, who thought liberal democracy is the "end of history." As I wrote in my recent column on a "private law society," we do not need legislation at all. This is one function of the pigsty we can easily dispense with.

What remains? There is only the task of "administering justice" - which means magistrates and judges. There is the task of administering cities and towns - which means mayors. There is not much else. None of these tasks require a pigsty.

Perhaps medieval England was better. There, parliament was only called upon to vote upon taxation. There was zero legislation. And the monarch was supreme as far as the "administration of justice" was concerned. Note that the monarch did not make new law. The House of Commons is "sovereign" today - but it makes new laws everyday, something no English sovereign ever did. I think the legal philosopher at fault is Blackstone - and it is interesting to note that his book was always under Abraham Lincoln's pillow. And Lincoln set up the great US Central State - Uncle Sam.

As far as our own Uncle Sham is concerned, I do believe everyone knows in their heart of hearts that it is the pigs of the pigsty who are the worst violators of all the laws of human morality and decency. Ask any beat constable or district magistrate who are the worst people in his area, and he will answer: the politicians. We must do without them - and without their pigsties.

Liberal democracy cannot be the "end of history." O'Rourke, Hoppe, the Maoists and I are united in thinking that it is a farce. There must be a better way - and I am looking for it. As the old Dylan classic goes:

There must be some way outta here,
Said the Joker to the Thief,
There's too much confusion,
I can get no relief.
Businessmen they drink my wine,
Ploughmen dig my earth,
None of them along the line,
Know what any of it is worth.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Parliament Is A Pigsty

The Maoists say that "the Indian parliament is a pigsty" - and I am forced to agree.

Read this about the Opposition (mainly Communist) talking about a "cut motion" on the Finance Bill to reverse price hikes - in "administered prices" - of petrol, diesel and fertilizers.

In reality, inflation is biting hard: we have double-digit inflation, and we do not have double-digit growth. Says a lot, if you know your Economics. But have Communists ever known anything about this subject? After all, they hate The Market. And they idolize The Total Chacha State.

Yes, inflation is everywhere. The prices of everything we buy here in Goa have gone up in the past few months - vegetables, provisions, milk, beer, cigarettes. You name it, and you will find that its price has sky-rocketed.

Why is this happening?

Answer: Because the Total Chacha State is printing money in excess. If more potatoes come to The Market, the price of potatoes goes down. Similarly, if more rupees come to The Market, the value of that money - its purchasing power in exchange - goes down.

As Ludwig von Mises wrote:

"The most important thing to remember is that inflation is not an act of God, that inflation is not a catastrophe of the elements or a disease that comes like the plague. Inflation is a policy."


It is the Total Chacha State that is following an inflationary policy. This is devastating for the poor.

Thus, it seems that the Government and the Opposition are in league over the inflationary policy - and Parliament indeed is a pigsty.

We need radical reform of government expenditure and borrowings if we want to tackle inflation. We also need "sound money."

A "cut motion" on the Finance Bill is mere tokenism by the Opposition. Citizens must see Chacha Manmohan as an inflationist. The must call for a defeat of the Finance Bill, for a pulling down of Chacha. No more inflationism.

On inflation, I have an excellent read to recommend today. It is by Doug French of the Mises Institute and he compares Ben Bernanke of the US Fed with Governor Gono of the Central Bank of Zimbabwe. Read it - and you will know how Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi and his cronies in government are just clones of Bernanke and Gono.

And Parliament, of course, is a pigsty.