Austro-Libertarian Natural Order Philosophy From Indyeah

Individualistic Austro-Libertarian Natural Order Philosophy From Indyeah
Showing posts with label Planning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Planning. Show all posts

Saturday, October 1, 2011

Say's Law versus The Marxists



The critical question before a poor nation like India is whether the market and laissez faire capitalism will raise our masses out of poverty - or should we stick to étatism? That is, how will the poor get "according to their needs"? Who will think of their needs, and invest in producing them - entrepreneurs or planners? Is Keynesian funny money financed welfare the way out? Say's Law holds the answer.


Say's Law of Markets says that if any poor person manages to sell his produce or services, he will be possessed of the means to demand non-competing goods on the market. This, as we have already discussed, implies the need for economic freedom.


Further, as also discussed yesterday in Part 2 of this 4-part series on Say's Law, modern capitalism is about mass production by Big Companies for mass consumption - by the poor, as in the case of shampoo in sachets or simple mobile phones. 


Thus, the poor, if possessed of economic freedom, will have the proverbial horn of plenty poured upon them by all the Big Companies. And many of them will be small investors in shares, too. In time, they will have TV sets, motorised personal transport, and what not. They will eat better, drink better, smoke better and live better. This is GUARANTEED if markets are free.


Now, this knocks the bottom out of the "iron law of wages" that Marxists believe in, as do Ricardian-Marxists like Piero Sraffa, whose blind follower teaches Economics at the IAS Academy. According to this law, the wages of workers must remain at subsistence. This is untrue - as proved above, looking at consumption. It is also proved by history - looking at the British working class during the 19th century, the heyday of classical liberalism, free trade and laissez faire. 


Further, if capital accumulation proceeds apace, and per-capita capital invested rises, the wages of all workers will also rise, because each one's productivity will rise. Ricardo erred on this score because he and the classical economists did not look at the consumer; nor did they know anything about "marginal productivity." Once we factor these concepts in, thanks to the advances made in economic theory by Menger and later Austrians, we can be sure that, if the Keynesians and the welfarists are prevented by public opinion from consuming capital, wages will rise along with consumption. Demand will continuously rise.


It must also be noted that if money is gold, inflation will end, and all prices will steadily fall - increasing consumption. The poor will inherit the earth.


So there are the following prescriptions:


1. Economic freedom.
2. Capital accumulation.
3. No funny money.
4. No welfarism.
5. No interventionism.
6. Laissez faire, laissez passer, laissez aller.


On the other side we have centralised economic planning - and Montek!


Now, the real Marxist question is: How will "each have according to his needs"? Montek is busy "measuring poverty" - for which purpose he has sanctioned State funds to hundreds of economists and statisticians, and confusion still prevails. When this confusion is finally settled, some poor people will get rice cheap. The planner will provide the poor with rice.


What is the market and the entrepreneur?


As Mises defined it, "the social function of the entrepreneur is to make provision for the uncertain future." It might rain - and so entrepreneurs invest - "make provision" - in making umbrellas. And shopkeepers stock them. If it rains, you can always get umbrellas. 


Now, smart entrepreneurs are ALWAYS surprising you with goods you never knew you needed. Smart entrepreneurs invest - "make provision" - to research consumer wants, they invest in R&D, and they come out with all kinds of surprises for satisfying unspoken needs. Skype is a great example. Poor people in India go to internet cafes and speak to loved ones abroad using Skype. It is cheap. And there is video. 


Meanwhile, the planner is thinking of rice. He has "made provision" for NOTHING. He is in perpetual DEFICIT. 


Anything to do with the market works - cars, mobile phones, civil aviation... anything. 


On the other hand, anything to do with the State fails - highways, railways, Air India, BSNL, electricity, water, drainage.


I think the choice should be clear.


Away with the Marxists!

Away with the planners!

Away with the socialists!

Away with the Keynesians!

Away with the welfarists!


Away with the protectionists!


Away with the trade unionists!


Away with the interventionists!


Away with immigration controls!


Laissez faire capitalism - for the poor!




PS: The final summing up post can be read here.

Monday, September 12, 2011

Memories of Montek Singh Ahluwalia and his wife Isher Judge Ahluwalia



I have met Montek Singh Ahluwalia just once - at the launch of Deepak Lal's book Reviving the Invisible Hand: The Case for Classical Liberalism in the Twenty-first Century at the India International Centre in Nude Elly. By the time Montek, then Deputy Chairman of our Planning Commission, entered the room - late, of course - the dais was occupied by Lal and Swaminathan Aiyar of The Economic Times. Upon seeing Montek, Swami said:

Hey! Montek! How come you wear blue turbans in Delhi and pink ones in Washington DC?


Interesting, what?


Speaking on this important book by India's greatest living free-market economist, Montek mumbled this and that, admitting he had not had the time to read the book as yet. I wanted to ask him whether he had read any of Lal's previous books - like The Poverty of "Development Economics" which asserted that poverty was sustained - and would be eternally perpetuated - by this pseudo-science. But the moderator closed the session down.


As for Isher Judge Ahluwalia, my first encounter with her was over the telephone, during the days when I was Editor of "The Tuesday Debate" on the op-ed page of The Economic Times. Every week, I had to choose a topic of debate and three debaters. For that week, I had decided upon Isher and, after obtaining her number from one of the secretaries, dialled it - and her secretary picked up. She was then Director-General of the Indian Council for International Economic Relations (ICRIER). I told her secretary who I was and why I was calling. But, as soon as Isher came on the line, she asked me if I would be willing to write a paper for her! Thereafter, our conversation went as follows:


Me:        A paper on what?

Isher:    Poverty.

Me:        But I am NOT interested in poverty!

Isher:    What interests you then?

Me:         Prosperity!

Isher:     But poverty is a huge industry!


Interesting, what?


I actually met Isher Judge Ahluwalia just once, some years later, at a student seminar organised by the Centre for Civil Society (CCS). I was the second speaker of the day, but I came in early to hear her. She spoke what these students hear in their classrooms every day, and she lauded all the professors who taught her at the Delhi School of (Mathematical) Economics. I wondered as to why CCS had invited her at all - that too, as the Chief Guest.


After her talk, there was a group photograph - but I decided not to be at the centre of the group alongside her, standing on the extreme right instead. One of the students asked as to why I was not standing next to the Chief Guest. My answer:


I am on her Extreme Right.

Friday, July 1, 2011

The Trial Of chacha manmohan s gandhi - Part 3: Take #2

The first post in this series referred to the charge levelled against Dr. Karl Marx at the LSE's Old Theatre - of "having wasted the time of humanity with his theories." 


In yesterday's post, the second of this series, I also pointed out that the entire "miseducation system" that chacha manmohan s gandhi has deliberately designed seeks to waste the precious years of youth in pointless - and intellectually damaging - pursuits. This delays their entry into The Market; it delays marriage by delaying the ability of young people to support themselves; and, what is worse, it corrupts sexual morality by keeping young boys and girls in college where all they do is "party." This is precisely what is happening in the USSA and elsewhere.


Now, time is of the essence. Life is measured in time. Productivity is measured in time. The wages of labour are paid according to time. Interest is charged according to time. Rents are also paid on the basis of time. It is therefore Time that is the most important "factor of production." Our chacha is wasting time - the most precious years of youth.


But it doesn't stop there.


Throughout India, our horrible transport system wastes time on a colossal scale. Our trains are the world's slowest; and as for our "notional highways," the less said the better. I do believe chacha has deliberately not built proper highways in order to FORCE our people to travel by train, which are his MONOPOLY. Modern buses on modern highways would have given the Indian Railways a run for their money. No one travels by train in the USSA because they have Greyhound buses and good highways.


And what about civil aviation? Our chacha has imposed such heavy taxes on "low cost" airlines that, once again, we are FORCED to travel by his unsafe and slow trains, his MONOPOLY.


I also believe our chacha has taken deliberate measures to ensure that the automobile revolution does NOT happen in India. He has done this deliberately in order to protect his cronies - like Rahul Bajaj MP, whose FUCKED-UP auto-rickshaws clog all the streets in all our cities and towns. Actually, Calcutta had an excellent PRIVATE tramway before the automobile was invented. Private tramways in all our small cities and towns would deliver the two- and three-wheeler industry a death-blow.


Further, our chacha has not pursued an "automobile policy" that seeks to ensure that all Indians have cars; rather, he wants all Indians to own motorcycles and scooters, thereby making their lives unsafe, especially when little children have to be ferried about. He is NOT protecting the people and their kids; he is protecting some bozos who cannot compete with duty-free second-hand car, bus and truck imports.


Amazing, ain't it? We fuckers have to sit "competitive examinations" all through our lives - CAT, IIT-JEE, UPSC et. al. But these cronies must be protected at all costs, and kept safe from competition.


One of the costs of such protectionism is human life - our lives. Over 200,000 people die on our unsafe streets and highways - and many times more are seriously injured. But our chacha, the great Central Planner, Chairman of the Planning Commission, would rather provide us with "food security." He seems to be unaware that billions of tonnes of fruit, vegetables and fish rot throughout India because these perishable commodities cannot reach markets on TIME.


Last evening, I had a great dinner off a roadside stall here in Pondicherry: dosas with fried chicken liver. Excellent! I told the vendor that he was engaged in true "social service" - and that the Pondicherry "Food Minister" was engaged in theft.


Since our chacha has also monopolised the teaching of History, I think he has deliberately kept the Babur Nama out of the curriculum, because therein this Great Mughal writes that he was horrified when, after conquering Dilli, he found there was "no cooked food available in the bazaars." He took immediate steps to ensure that this was rectified and Mughlai kebabs were available for the populace. 


Our chacha, the great History teacher, wants to parcel raw rice and wheat to all Indians! In the meantime, ask any street-food vendor in Nude Elly (or anywhere else) as to how much harassment he faces daily from chacha's khaki-costumed goons.


Theatre of the absurd, ain't it?


While we are all wasting Time, it is noteworthy that our great chacha himself has NO TIME TO WASTE. 


There is a lead editorial in The Hindu of today that points to the fact that our great chacha "has held only two press conferences and two interactions with editors in Delhi in the past seven years. As for interviews, he has allowed himself to be questioned by an Indian newspaper only once and never by an Indian [television] news channel."


In other words, these seven or eight long years of chacha's misrule have been a colossal waste of time - for the Free Press, a vital Institution of Freedom, to which I proudly belong, with a track record of 20 years of distinguished service.


Now, as the ancient proverb goes, "Time is money." 


Of course, chacha's fiat paper money loses value with the ticking of the clock. The inflationist-welfarist-Keynesian bozo!


It is HIGH TIME this waster of time and money was shown the door - Exeunt! as The Bard would put it - and this vast sub-continent got down to the serious business of making money by saving Time, which is the only way Productivity can be raised, thereby raising all wages and incomes. 


We need a wholesale transport revolution. 


We need "street security" not "food security."


And we need Sound, Private Money, which will give all our poor people "financial security." Inflationism erodes the Capital of all. And welfarism is nothing but "capital consumption."


[This will be a 5-part series. Stay tuned for more.]

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

The Philosopher's Stone

After those horrible weeks in Orissa, it was sheer delight to be in tiny Pondicherry - and civilisation. Shops, shops and more shops, bars and restaurants, masses of people everywhere, and even lots of bright neon lights. 

This small city was built by the French, the roads all neatly arranged in a "grid pattern." The central market area is called Grand Bazaar - and in 1985, I served briefly as the head of Grand Bazaar Police Station. I always recall those days, and those years, for I spent close to three years here, because while I headed Grand Bazaar PS, there was NO CRIME reported. During those years, I noticed that the people are all "god-fearing and law-abiding" and that a "natural order" prevailed. I saw that something was seriously wrong with Thomas Hobbes' view that without The State there would ensue "a war of each against all." There was no such war in Pondicherry. There was only one murder - of an MLA, and that is "political crime." Also, I personally saw the local police tear up the "history sheet" of a newly appointed CONgress minister! I found police work so boring, that I even resigned, but that's another story.

Today, I walked down these streets and their bazaars again, where perfect order prevails, wearing a t-shirt saying:

DON'T STEAL.
The Government Hates Competition.

Today, after over 20 years of "private investigations," a long "intellectual journey," I have found out why this natural order exists. It is so simply because we are all "rule following animals." Apart from religious and cultural rules, we follow commercial rules - and this results in a "commercial culture." Pondicherry exemplifies this culture as, indeed, does any place in this vast sub-continent. The existence of this commercial culture is what civilisation is all about, with its cities, their markets, and all the shops. A "nation of shopkeepers" is really what we are.

Yet, even here, as elsewhere, the truth of what my t-shirt says is evident. Much of the place, especially the commercial areas, is a mess; and traffic is worse than hell itself. In my time, most people rode cycles; today, they have progressed to motorcycles. No one has thought of tramways because I presume they have to apply to some "planner" in Nude Elly for permission. All the "political parties" are centralised, as is the IAS-IPS bureaucracy. All report to Nude Elly. And what an almighty mess Nude Elly is!

I strolled along the Beach Road promenade last night, as I used to do with my dog those long years ago, and passed the Governor's house, with its cannons mounted at the gates. There was a diesel generator on! And it is this The State that produces electricity! Sure enough, the electricity failed in my hotel. I passed a dental college set up by this State, which also runs a University and many schools. I saw a guy wearing a t-shirt saying "Studying Sucks!"

This is the fundamental error our nation has made. We have not sought Prosperity, Peace, Order and Knowledge in The Grand Bazaar; rather, we have asked the guys with the guns, with cannons at their gates, to deliver these to us. Error. The fact that these guys are clueless has already been brought out in previous posts.

Today, what I would like to add is that the guys with cannons at their gates, whether here or in Nude Elly, are issuing wrong commands to their own staff, their personnel. In the liberal scheme of things, the State does NOT command The Market. Rather, it commands its own staff to see that enemies of this market order are brought to justice. This is NOT happening. From Nude Elly you just hear nonsense about free rice for the poor and free and forced education for all, and, of course, the MGNREGA-bullshit; you never hear of all the important things that must be done in each of our cities and towns by the local people themselves, who possess the "local knowledge." They give orders to close down shops at 10pm. They give orders to harass smokers. They don't do any "useful work." This is particularly true of the Traffic Police. And this is true all over India.

Note that the masses of people roaming around in the bazaars are NOT "organised" into any "society." They are truly a "cosmos" of individual stars, an "order without design." Socialists wanted to organise and regiment such a cosmos into what Nehru called a "socialistic pattern of society" based on economic equality. It is from that point on that the guys with the guns got it wrong. And from Chacha Nehru to chacha manmohan it has been a long, downhill journey. As BR Shenoy asked of these planners, way back in the 1950s, is India to achieve "planned progress or planned chaos"? Today, it should be obvious, this IS planned chaos - especially on the streets, and we are fortunate if there are any streets at all, because these guys want to make steel and fly planes - and, of course, "educate" all the kids. 

Over my dead body, I say. For I was one of those "miseducated" kids myself. On my very first day at Hindu College, Delhi University, in 1974, there to study for a BA degree with Honours in Economics, I was taught The Theory of the Vicious Circle of Poverty. This says that poor people and poor nations are destined to remain poor forever - unless they receive outside aid, which can come from their own State, or from "foreign aid."

This was taught to me and millions of other Indians almost exactly 200 years after Adam Smith's An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), in which he said we are all blessed by our creator with "a natural propensity to truck, barter and exchange." You see little children exchanging toys and other things amongst each other: like "give me some of your chips and I'll give you a sip of my cola." The instinct to trade is "natural." In my boarding school, we boys even developed our own "medium of exchange" - our money - and these were marbles. If you wanted something from someone else, you gave him some marbles, and different kinds of marbles had different values. That is the miracle of the trading, human mind. It needs NO COMMANDS.

The idea of a "command economy" is what has made this into a Predatory State. The commander is evil. He is possessed of two great big evil eyes. And a great big evil mind. If you want to survive, if you want your children to survive - the same children they call the "population problem" - and, most importantly, if you want this wonderful civilisation to survive, all these cities and towns, these shops and markets, these evil people must be overthrown.

Forthwith! 

If I may add, poverty is a HUGE MOTIVATOR. Poor people always struggle hard to succeed, while the children of the rich usually get addicted to luxury and vice, idling their lives away. A great big fortune made by one generation is usually completely dissipated by the next two, rarely built upon. I hope you see what a great big lie they taught me, on my very first day in class, under the head of "Economic Theory."

Song of the Day: Van Morrison's, here.

Sunday, June 19, 2011

The Haunted, Frightened Tree Of Complete Ignorance

Vaclav Klaus regaled me with the story of how some World Bank - IMF "economists" phoned him when he assumed office as President of the Czech Republic, seeking an appointment so that they could offer him "advice." He told them he knew more Economics than them, and did not need their advice. Fuck off from Prague, dudes, he told them. Return to Washington DC or wherever the fuck you came from.

Sonia Gandhi has a National Advisory Council (NAC). She needs advice. Why does she need advice? Because she is Ignorant. According to Shekhar Gupta of the Indian Express, these "darbari jholawallahs" of the NAC are "IAS dropouts and retirees." These guys have dreamt up a new scheme for promoting "rural livelihood." But markets are in crowded cities and towns - not in the vacant countryside. As Adam Smith said in the very first chapter of the Wealth of Nations, "the extent of the division of labour is limited by the size of the market." The Principle of the Division of Labour, by which we all specialise, is what Ludwig von Mises called the "principle of cosmic change and becoming." Each of us chooses to "become" someone - singer, dancer, actor, writer, whatever. We do not all sit in villages and spin yarn for our own use. We are NOT "self-sufficient." We specialise - and this requires physical marketplaces in physical cities and towns.

While Sonia Gandhi and her darbari baboons dream of a rural utopia, it is worth noting that all our cities and towns are disasters, including Nude Elly. These socialists built three cities in the past 60 years - while the Bris built 80 "hill-stations" in 50 years - and all three are State Capitals: Chandigarh, Gandhinagar, and Bhubaneshwar, where I am now located. 

I travelled around Bhubaneshwar a fair bit by auto-rickshaw yesterday, and the broad roads lined with trees are all for The State, just like Nude Elly. I asked the driver to take me to the Central Commercial District - and there was none. At least the Brits built Connaught Place, grandly designed. 

In Bhubaneshwar, the streets where shops are located are all disasters - and this affects the poorest of the poor, who eke out their "livelihoods" on the streets, since they cannot afford proper shops. They sell bananas, coconuts, pakoras and what not - this is the division of labour. And you cannot sell coconuts where there is no market - which is the vacant village.

Population causes Prosperity - in cities and towns, and their markets.

While Sonia Gandhi and her darbari baboons dream of rural schemes by which huge amounts of fraudulent money will be spent by younger IAS baboons, the fact remains that poor people from villages are continuously coming to these ghastly cities and towns - and getting fucked. See the jhugggis of Nude Elly, the slums of Bombay and Calcutta, and from my train window I saw the poor of Bhubaneshwar too, trying to survive in huts by the railway track. All around is ABUNDANT UNOWNED LAND.

There is the metaphysical - and there is the physical: cities and towns are our Fixed Capital. City and Town Roads are Social Capital: they are "public thoroughfares" and hence "collective property." They are NOT investing in these because they know not what Capital is, the life blood of Capitalism. Rather, they are "consuming capital" - which is the highway to "de-civilisation." The Professor of Economics at the IAS Academy in Mussoorie is a Marxist - as I reported on the Barkha Dutt Show many years ago.

There is "authority" - and sometimes there comes about the total absence of authority, because of Ignorance. The Delhi Development "Authority" is NOT an acknowledged "authority" on anything: just check out the disaster called Vasant Kunj, built and designed by a bunch of assholes. Similarly, the National Highway "Authority" of India is NOT an "authority" on highways - which would be Gabriel Roth. Our National Highways are all "notional highways." The Traffic Police know nothing of the science and technology of traffic management. Everything about The State is marked by complete and total Ignorance. From top to bottom. And they want to teach your children!

The Science of Economics is the most important science for humanity to know and understand. I am proud to be an Independent Authority in this science.

And as for our The Corrupt & Ignorant State Devoid of all Authority - I have only pure contempt. You look at human society with the "evil eye" - the buri nazar. You desire not that each Indian youngster "becomes" what he or she wants to become. You desire only that they become your servants - that is, "government servants." So you want to employ "the masses" in your "work schemes." You are inventing work in villages - and stealing all the money through your "political and bureaucratic organisation" - while, simultaneously, you are hurting all livelihoods in cities and towns. In Bombay, girls can't dance free. In Nude Elly only The State can open booze shops. In Bhubaneshwar I saw many "musical bands" who had set up their counters on a roadside. One said "Brass Band." And one actually said "ROCK BAND." There are no bars in the city where live music is played. What is "knowledge"? And how much of it comes from schools, and books?

If the CONgress is so ignorant, the Opposition is even worse. The BJP's slogan remains the metaphysical - a God, and his Temple. As if any God can be found in temples. I smoked a chillum with a sadhu in Gangotri. He told me the people worshipping at the temple there were fools, and God is found in solitude, in peace, and in the Holy Smoke. Instead of the metaphysical Lord Ram the BJP has given us Narendra Modi at the top and Dara Singh at the bottom. They are as evil and ignorant as the CONgress; maybe worse. And then we have the Commies - the most Ignorant people ever born. Democracy is also metaphysical. The "power of the vote" is no power; and most people don't vote. So there must be someway outta here. And that lies in Liberty.

I conclude this post with two quotes Peter Bauer ended his essay on "The Disregard of Reality" with - an elegant essay penned on the disaster mainstream Economics has become, written towards the end of a long and productive life championing Liberty for the poor of the Third World. The first is from Pascal, and it goes:

"Let us labour at trying to think clearly: herein lies the source of moral conduct."

And the second is from George Orwell, a socialist hero who did see the horrors of statism:

"We have sunk to such a depth that the restatement of the obvious has become the first duty of intelligent men."

Saturday, June 18, 2011

Amartya Sen... And His Evil Metaphysics

Amartya Sen, the only Indian "economist" to win the Nobel prize, received this award for his "contributions to the economics of welfare." This is an entirely metaphysical discipline, resting, as it does, on a mythical "social welfare function" that supposedly inhabits the minds of the wise, caring and benevolent personnel of The State. He has thus championed the "right to work" programmes of the mammoth MGNREGA, and his protege, Jean Dreze the "sociologist" - another metaphysical discipline - sits on the National Advisory Council with soniaji and they are now coming up with more and more nonsensical ideas, from cheap rice to what not. Mint has an editorial today on "another flawed rural scheme" - designed to "promote rural livelihood." This is the metaphysical social welfare function at work.

Reality suggest something else is at work - a Predatory State. I am living on Station Road, Bhubaneshwar; there is no road to my hotel, and the establishment does not possess a license to serve alcohol. There are very few such shops on this road, and last evening I had to walk more than a mile - through slush and filth - to obtain some beer, which has been heavily overtaxed. Poor people cannot afford this healthy drink - and their traditional toddy is banned. There goes an important "rural livelihood."

The same is true for ganja. There is a hole-in-the-wall shop just outside the station where I bought a tola of fuck-all smoke. If the stuff is being sold, then why not sell it openly? Liberate the people. Let them enjoy quality. Let us think like Amsterdam. Cannabliss Indica - and not the Tata Indica.

Amartya Sen does not believe in Liberty. His two anti-market and pro-State books are Development as Freedom and Rationality and Freedom. In the former he has argued that people cannot be free without "development" - which is something the chaps with the "social welfare function" embedded in their brains must bring about. In the latter, he has argued, quite unabashedly, that poor people cannot be free because they are NOT "rational." Hence they need his "education." I reviewed this book - most unfavourably - for the New York Sun, and you can find it online here. The review was titled "Why Amartya Sen Is An Enemy Of The Poor: Freedom Matters More Than Education."

Talking about education, I met some young students of electrical engineering on the train to Sambalpur. When I asked about their career prospects, they said their hopes lay in State employment - that is, working for the Orissa State Electricity Department. I advised them against it, saying they would be not only corrupted, they would also never learn anything about modern "technology." I advised them to work for private firms, preferably cutting-edge foreign firms. To drive my point home, I have the example of the State Railway we were riding. It did the 350km journey from Puri to Sambalpur in 7 hours, averaging 70 km an hour. A modern bus on a modern highway could have done the distance in less than three hours, I told them. So if you work for the State Railway, you will never "learn" anything about technology; all you will learn is corruption.

They are corrupting the minds of the youth with their metaphysics. They are corrupting all whom they employ. And there is surely no "social welfare function" in the mind of the Railway Minister, is there?

Amartya Sen comes from a generation that claims to have "fought for freedom." Utter nonsense! These guys merely wanted State Power - to unleash their own horrors on the poor people.

We need to fight for freedom again. This must begin with a freeing of our minds from their metaphysical delusions and seeing reality as what it is - a Predatory State writ large.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Fukuyama, Hayek, Sen - and a Cop

Francis Fukuyama, who once wrote a book arguing that liberal democracy is the "end of history," has reviewed a new edition of Friedrich Hayek's The Constitution of Liberty for the New York Times, in which he has pitted Amartya Sen against Hayek. Fukuyama writes:

There have always been two major critiques of Hayek’s arguments, neither of which are fully answered by a re­reading of “The Constitution of Liberty.” The first comes from the left. Hayek provides a very minimalist definition of freedom as freedom from coercion, and particularly coercion by a central government. But as the economist Amartya Sen has argued, the ability to actually take advantage of freedom depends on other things like resources, health and education that many people in a typical society do not possess.

Fukuyama does well to categorise Amartya Sen's critique of Hayek as "coming from the left." Sen is a "welfarist" – he won the 1998 Nobel prize for his work on “welfare economics” - and it is he who has championed and supported the "right to free and compulsory education" as well as the "right to food" and the "right to work." These are all disastrous ideas that merely serve the bureaucracy by giving them very big budgets to spend. All this big government spending does nothing for the poor - indeed, it actually hurts them by consuming precious capital and causing inflation.

Today, in India, we are suffering because Chacha Manmohan S Gandhi has followed Sen's ideas - as expressed in his Development as Freedom (1999) and its sequel Rationality and Freedom (2003). Sen's acolyte, the professor of sociology Jean Dreze, is a senior member of the National Advisory Council attached to Sonia Gandhi. In that position, Dreze supported all kinds of rights - except the Right to Property!

Fukuyama notes that:

Hayek always had problems getting the respect he deserved; even when he was awarded the Nobel in economic science in 1974, the awards committee paired him with the left-leaning economist Gunnar Myrdal.

Actually, Myrdal and Sen are more or less identical in their thinking: both believe that the masses are stupid - without "the ability to actually take advantage of freedom" - and that the baboos of our The State are an "intellectual-moral elite" who must plan the economy and take "collective decisions" on behalf of these dumb masses. These baboos must impart "education" to them, too.

It was Peter Bauer who demolished these nonsensical ideas – so contemptuous of the poor, and so much in praise of The State. And Bauer was a “development economist” who had studied the Third World - and the “informal sector” in which the poor operate - very closely.

Fukuyama therefore treads dangerous ground when he pits Sen against Hayek by writing in support of Sen’s claim that “the ability to actually take advantage of freedom depends on other things like resources, health and education that many people in a typical society do not possess.”

Did the bar dancers of Bombay lack “resources, health and education”? Do ganja farmers need freedom or welfare? Is Sen’s welfarism going to “help the poor”? Or do they need Freedom from the Centralised State? What about the Right to Property – the only solution to the “mystery of capital.”

Think things over – but I am on Peter Bauer’s side, opposed to both Myrdal as well as Sen. You can read my (unfavourable) review of Sen’s Rationality and Freedom, published in the New York Sun, here.


As far as the critique of Hayek that "comes from the right" - the charge of "moral relativism" that Fukuyama mentions - the philosopher Tibor Machan rebuts it roundly here. Machan concludes:
The relationship between objective personal morality and the principles of politics which are basic to a constitution such as Hayek's constitution of liberty is a challenging aspect of political philosophy. It does not help to casually dismiss Hayek's approach by caricaturing it as moral relativism.
After writing The Constitution of Liberty (1960), Hayek published three volumes on Law, Legislation & Liberty between 1973-79, and then The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism in 1988. He died in 1992 – at the age of 92. So it cannot be said that The Constitution of Liberty was his last word on the subject. Indeed, in Law, Legislation & Liberty he outlined the respective spheres of “private law” and “public law” – the latter being legislation. These pioneering ideas have been carried forward by many since then: you can read Hans-Hermann Hoppe arguing very strongly in favour of a private law society here. I have also written a brief column on this subject, available here.

Fukuyama concludes his review by saying that Hayek “proves himself to be far more of a hubristic Cartesian than a true Hayekian.” Actually, it is in the first volume of Law, Legislation & Liberty – titled “Rules and Order” – that Hayek demolished Cartesian rationalism and “legal positivism.” Fukuyama ought to read this too. Also, the Hayekian insight that when we buy and sell in the market we do so “between instinct and reason” – the opening chapter of The Fatal Conceit – proves that Fukuyama’s assessment of Hayek is totally unfounded.

To conclude: Here in Goa, the people suffer from various repressive pieces of legislation passed by the Central State – from the Coastal Zone Regulation Act to the Narcotics & Psychotropic Substances Act. Both are in violation of the Right to Property – a right not guaranteed to us by the socialist Constitution of India.

The other day I had a chance to interact with a Goan cop. I told him to resign from service – pointing out that he was doing “bad work” and not “good work.” There were quite a few Goan people listening in on our discussions – and they all agreed with me. In the end, the cop agreed too!

This itself is proof of the fact that our The State is repressive – and that the people need Freedom and Property. It was a vindication of Hayek’s contention that “liberty, property and law are an inseparable trinity.” So much for Amartya Sen and his “welfarism.” This welfarism funded by Keynesianism is the bane of India, detrimental to the poor. It must give way to Liberty and Sound Money.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

It's Clientelism, Not Federalism

The news is that the Central Planning Commission has approved Goa's Annual Plan of Rs. 3320 crores (or 3.23 billion rupees) - and the photo on the front page showed Goa's chief minister, Digamber Kamat of the CONgress, with chhota ustad montek, the IMF man who heads the Planning Commission in Nude Elly.

This gives the impression that the Centre is "allocating resources" appropriately, so that Goa can "develop." Yet, the truth is the very opposite. Much of this money is printed or borrowed money - and this retards development, while also fuelling inflation. Goans do not gain with such spending; rather, they lose. As I pointed out the other day, "the more they spend, the more you lose." Indeed, the more there is of "government growth" - in terms of either powers or budgets - the less the people grow, the less private businesses grow.

What is really going on here?

Is this "federalism"? I don't think so. What is obvious is that Goa is a "client" of the Centre, receiving money from Nude Elly in exchange for loyalty. The CONgress chief minister of Goa is part of the Party Apparatus headquartered in 10, Janpath.

Actually, even the Civics textbooks do not claim that India is "federal." They say India is "quasi-federal" - which ought to mean that India is "quasi-unitary." Had ours been a real federation, the transfer of resources would have been the other way around, with Goa collecting its own resources and spending these on what Goa needs (like roads) - while also sending a small portion to finance the Centre, which will have very limited tasks to perform. This "inverted pyramid" is called "subsidiarity" - and is based on the idea that local government comes first. I have an old post on this concept, basic to de-centralisation.

Subsidiarity matters in Goa as well. Although this is a tiny state, there are 3 major cities and over 30 towns with municipal organisation. And it cannot be denied that all these cities and towns are collapsing. The fishing hamlets by the sea where tourists flock in the season are also pictures of neglect.

Goa needs mayors too. It is from Goa's cities and towns that taxes are collected. These should ideally be spent in the city or town itself, while some portion of these should be sent upwards, to Panjim and (maybe) Nude Elly.

I say "maybe" because Goan feni - of which I had three large shots last night - is not allowed entry into the rest of India. Nor does Nude Elly's "trade policy" allow Goa to import freely through its "major port," Marmugao. This port is today another "iron ore exporter." Recall that the Magna Carta gave all Englishmen the "freedom to trade by land and sea."

Interestingly, in the Plan that has just been approved by montek, Rs.500 crores has been allocated for the "mining areas." The news report makes no mention of any funds allocated to the cities and towns of Goa for local Capital investments like roads and footpaths - which they desperately need. Instead, almost all the money has been allocated for various "welfare schemes." In other words, politicians loyal to Nude Elly and IAS baboos will get all this money for loose spending - that is, building clientelistic networks of their own. There is no "economics" to this Plan; it is all about "politics." This is only natural in a socialist country that despises the Free Market and makes politics the means to economic gain. All immorality and corruption stem from this ideology.

Politics and politicians in Goa are much the same as anywhere else in India - and this is a tragedy. Many important ministers are under a cloud. It is a mirror-image of Nude Elly. Dirty politics.

Recommended reading: My article from 2007 titled "Goa must secede."

Monday, February 21, 2011

Constitutionalism - And Its Failure

As the fires of revolt and revolution spread around the world, and these oppressed peoples look for solutions like constitutions, it seems to me that these opening paragraphs from Friedrich Hayek's Law, Legislation & Liberty (Volume I: Rules and Order; University of Chicago Press, 1973) could serve as a much needed guide in such troubled times.

When Montesquieu and the framers of the American Constitution articulated the conception of a limiting constitution that had grown up in England, they set a pattern which liberal constitutionalism has followed ever since. Their chief aim was to provide institutional safeguards of individual freedom; and the device in which they placed their faith was the separation of powers. In the form in which we know this division of power between the legislature, the judiciary and the administration, it has not achieved what it was meant to achieve. Governments everywhere have obtained by constitutional means powers which those men had meant to deny them. The first attempt to secure individual liberty by constitutions has evidently failed.

Constitutionalism means limited government. But the interpretation given to the traditional formulae of constitutionalism has made it possible to reconcile these with a conception of democracy according to which this is a form of government where the will of the majority on any particular matter is unlimited. As a result it has already been seriously suggested that constitutions are an antiquated survival which have no place in the modern conception of government. And, indeed, what function is served by a constitution which makes omnipotent government possible? Is its function merely that governments work smoothly and efficiently, whatever their aims?

In these circumstances it seems important to ask what those founders of liberal constitutionalism would do today if, pursuing the aims they did, they could command all the experience we have gained in the meantime. There is much we ought to have learned from the history of the last two hundred years that those men with all their wisdom could not have known. To me their aims seem to be as valid as ever. But as their means have proved inadequate, new institutional invention is needed.

The footnotes to this section contain some definitions of constitutionalism that I am appending below:

1. "The original idea behind constitutions is that of limiting government and of requiring those who govern to conform to laws and rules."

2. "All constitutional government is by definition limited government... constitutionalism has one essential quality: it is a legal limitation of government; it is the antithesis of arbitrary rule; its opposite is despotic government, the government of will."

3. "Constitutionalism is the process by which governmental action is effectively restrained."

Immediately thereafter, another footnote says this of modern Democracy:

"The modern conception of Democracy is of a form of government in which no restriction is placed upon the governing body."

In the opening chapter titled "Reason and Evolution" Hayek tells us where we went wrong - and it all begins with not understanding that human society is a self-generating spontaneous order. The order is completely "natural" because man is a "rule-following animal" - but these rules have never been formally articulated, like Private Property. Thus, the illiterate crowds in our teeming bazaars are following these rules - which learned constitutional lawyers are unaware of - and that is why perfect order prevails, and posses of armed policemen are unnecessary. 

Hayek then goes on to point out our philosophical errors - the constructive rationalism of Rene Descartes and his contemporary Thomas Hobbes. In that Age of Reason, these ideas popularised the dangerous fiction that human society could be "designed anew" - by legislators. It was only during the Scottish Enlightenment that David Hume, Adam Ferguson and Adam Smith articulated the opposing viewpoint: that human society is an "order without design." Or that the natural spontaneous order we inhabit is "a product of human action and not human design," as Ferguson put it, in his An Essay on the History of Civil Society (1767). In a footnote, Hayek quotes from the introduction by Duncan Forbes to the 1966 reprint of this book, in which Forbes writes that the "superstition" that Legislators are Founders of States was precisely that these Scots destroyed:


The Legislator myth flourished in the eighteenth century, for a variety of reasons, and its destruction was perhaps the most original and daring coup of the social science of the Scottish Enlightenment.

It is only after studying these men that Charles Darwin conceived his theories of evolution - another "order without design." I have an earlier post on this.

And it was Carl Menger, founder of the Austrian school of Economics, who put it best when he wrote, in his discourse on the methodology of the social sciences (1883):

How can it be that institutions which serve the common welfare and are extremely significant for its development come into being without a ‘common will’ directed towards their establishment?

Markets have not been designed, just as languages have not. Nor have morals. Money was not invented by one mind - and certainly not that of a great ruler. All have evolved.

Ludwig von Mises must also be invoked here, for it is he who pointed out where true freedom lies:

"What gives to the individuals as much freedom as is compatible with life in society is the operation of the market economy. The constitutions and bills of rights do not create freedom."

The errors of the Cartesian-Hobbesian kind have only been multiplied by modern socialists - who speak of "social engineering" as though humanity is just putty waiting to be given shape by omniscient and omnipotent legislators. Rousseau typifies such nonsense. As with Hobbes, so with Rousseau, both popularised the false notion that society is formed by a "social contract" - and it from these errors that the problems of modern constitutionalism stem. Indeed, Contract is but Private Law. The only social contracts are treaties.

The true picture, that men are "rule-following," allows us to see Law as natural and evolved - though not articulated - and Legislation as interference, as democratic totalitarianism, and as an enemy of individual Liberty as well as a ceaseless violation of Private Property.

Without Legislation, human society would not be lawless - on the contrary, we would peacefully thrive in a "private law society."

The rebels and revolutionaries of today must therefore look towards the English Magna Carta of 1215 AD as their guide - for this is when constitutionalism began, by limiting the sovereign and guaranteeing the liberties of the people.  However, since modern democratic governments have exceeded their constitutional bounds, new limits need to imposed upon them, some of which I have attempted to outline in a previous post:

  • Freedom in the choice of media of exchange. That is, an end to the fiat money monopoly; the end of “legal tender.” Fiat paper notes can circulate – but we are free to refuse them. This will impose financial discipline on The State. Inflationism will finally end. Capital will be accumulated - not consumed. Poor people will benefit greatly.


  • The Inviolability of Private Property by any actions on the part of The State – either through Legislation or through its lawless agents.This will guarantee Liberty.


  • Freedom from the National Debt: that is, an end to State borrowing. This will impose further restrictions on recklessness and irresponsibility in State spending, while also securing the prosperity of future generations.

Unlimited government, which is arbitrary power, is an extremely destructive thing, much to be abhorred by all who desire human welfare. As Trenchard and Gordon, both Whigs (and Hayek preferred to call himself a Whig rather than a "conservative") put it in Cato's Letters, way back in the England of the 1720s:

There is something so wanton and monstrous in lawless Power, that there scarce ever was a human Spirit that could bear it; and the Mind of Man, which is weak and limited, ought never to be trusted with a Power that is boundless. The State of Tyranny is a State of War....

Power is like Fire; it warms, scorches, or destroys, according as it is watched, provoked or increased. It is as dangerous as useful. Its only Rule is the Good of the People; but because it is apt to break its Bounds, in all good Governments nothing, or as little as may be, ought to be left to Chance, or the Humours of Men in Authority: All should proceed by fixed and stated Rules....

This demonstrates the inestimable Blessing of Liberty. Can we ever over-rate it, or be too jealous of a Treasure which includes in it almost all Human Felicities? Or can we encourage too much those that contend for it, and those that promote it? It is the Parent of Virtue, Pleasure, Plenty, and Security; and 'tis innocent, as well as lovely. In all Contentions between Liberty and Power, the latter has almost constantly been the Aggressor. Liberty, if ever it produces any Evils, does also cure them: Its worst Effect, Licentiousness, never does, and never can, continue long. Anarchy cannot be of much Duration: and where 'tis so, it is the Child and Companion of Tyranny; which is not Government, but a Dissolution of it, as Tyrants are Enemies of Mankind.

I trust I have provided all those good people who are fighting their domestic tyrants and seeking their Liberty with plenty food for serious thought. Good luck to you all. May all tyrannies end. And may Liberty triumph.

Monday, December 27, 2010

Choose Between Shopkeepers And Planners


In my previous post, I wrote how "improved consumption" should be seen as a sign of "economic development." Since there are many among us who deride "consumerism," allow me to elaborate. After all, from the 1950s to the 1990s, why did millions of Indians migrate to the West - if not for "improved consumption"? If some nations are considered "developed" today, the only reason for this status is that their citizens are able to consume more and better goods. In the socialist India I grew up in, there was nothing at all to consume. The fact that the Indian consumer is far better provided for today than he was then is in itself proof of the validity of "economic reforms" in the 1990s. So let us not underrate the importance of consumption. Consumption is the goal of all production. We produce in order to consume.

In that post, I discussed the Bania shopkeeper:

In the small market town 3 kms from the village where I live in south Goa - the only market town in a vast, rural (and forested) district - is a Bania shopkeeper. His little shop is always crowded with poor villagers who come from miles around to buy this or that, in very small quantities. And he never fails them. I always get my carton of cigarettes from him - and he stocks hundreds of other goods. We should pause to appreciate the tremendous amount of diligence that goes into running such a shop, upon which so many rely, and how he "improves their consumption." When shops and markets close, people suffer - especially in far-flung parts of the empire. We may also note that all the mathematics the Bania uses are the four operations of Arithmetic.


Some additional points need to be noted: First, that this Bania, like all entrepreneurs, "makes provision for the uncertain future." When he buys his stocks, his mind is on the future needs of his customers, which he tries to successfully anticipate. Further: he invests his own money in provisioning for that future. He is a capitalist and speculator - and he "serves the people" in a very important way, and that is by improving their consumption.

Now, there are two ways by which we can pursue "economic development" - one is by using such shopkeepers as the vehicle, and the other is by using the central planners of The State.

When we contrast shopkeepers with planners, we see that the two perform very different kinds of "work." The shopkeeper has his eye on physical stocks and their rate of depletion as he sells hundreds of goods to his customers. The planner has no customers. The planner studies government files and government reports. On the basis of the recommendations in these files, the planner decides to allocate "public capital" towards certain projects aimed at improving the lives of the people. All these projects are executed by the bureaucracy. In all these cases, the bureaucracy benefits - not the people, whose needs remain unsatisfied, despite all the complex mathematics and detailed statistics. It is no coincidence that anything planned is in short supply - like roads and electricity. Only entrepreneurs can produce "goods"; governments produce "bads."

Let us also not forget that the planner is spending money that does not even exist - by borrowing and by printing - and that both taxation and inflation impair consumption.

We in India therefore have to choose between the Market and the State. We must see that only shopkeepers and free trade can improve our material lives - not planners. We must call for a completely free economy.

No more 5-year plans. No more "Indian Economics" textbooks.

I have been singing this song for a long, long time. Barely a week into my stint as editorial writer for The Economic Times (1998-2002) I wrote one titled "Close it down, Monty" in which Montek, then heading the Planning Commission, was advised to close down this house of horrors. The next morning, I was surprised to find that my editorial had not appeared. I called the editor and he replied that he simply could not publish such an opinion. I immediately offered to quit - for I said I was unwilling to co-exist with central planning. The edit was published the next day. The time has now come for more and more journalists to think along these lines - and shout, "Close it down, Monty."

Monday, December 13, 2010

There Is No "Model" Of Liberty


The headline read: "Privatisation is not a solution for development" - and I clicked. Here is what I found.

The finance minister of Kerala, Thomas Issac, while speaking at a three-day annual international conference of the Network of Asia-Pacific Schools and Institutes of Public Administration and Governance (NAPSIPAG) at the Institute of Management in Government in Thiruvananthapuram, said that "privatisation is not a solution for development in Kerala."

What is the solution then, Mr. Minister? - nationalisation? PSUs?

The minister was arguing in favour of the "Kerala Model of Development."

According to the minister, "
Development has to be designed in such a manner that emphasis is laid on decentralised participatory governance."

Frankly, this mantra of "decentralised participatory governance" is NOT what they practise. Kerala - like all our other states - has a State Planning Board, and two of its Members participated in these discussions. There is a Central Planning Commission in Delhi. Ours is a centralised State. The political parties are centralised. So is the bureaucracy.

Since only politicians and bureaucrats engage in State Planning, this is always "authoritarian."

It is The Market, on the other hand, that is completely "de-centralised," for its ultimate driving force is The Individual, in his capacity as a Consumer. Whereas he is alone, the fact remains that all the "higher" actors - the entrepreneurs, the technologists, the capitalists - they are trying to succeed by anticipating as well as satisfying the future needs of consumers as a "class." Consumers are "served" in markets - not "ruled."

The extremely worthy goal of "development" - which is an "economic goal" - can ONLY be accomplished by The Market.

"Economic development" in The Market is is an Individual Economic Achievement. It is based on Individual Knowledge.

These Individual Economic Achievements fund Taxation - which funds "State welfare" - which is something else. Welfare is NOT an "economic achievement."

The minister says, "
the State would have to shift its development path with stress on knowledge-based and skill-based industries."

Earlier, I have quoted him saying, "Development has to be designed in such a manner that emphasis is laid on decentralised participatory governance."

As the italicised portions above show, this very "idea" is Centralised. Some Centralised Mind has to "design" development and "shift this path."

But all entrepreneurship and speculation is about The Future!

The Market works to satisfy almost all our myriad needs, because there are billions of individuals trying to satisfy future needs of "the masses" - all the unknown strangers out there.

In this market-based exchange order, "knowledge is fragmented."

That is why it works.

For the Future.

And "Five-Year Plans" are also about a future - the future thought of by a Centralised Mind.

Kerala "exports" its literate youth. There are no opportunities for them to make "economic achievements" in their own state. A good country attracts immigrants. People flee from bad countries. People have been fleeing communist Bengal for decades now. Millions tried to flee communist East Germany - and were shot!

The Kerala Model of Development doesn't work. It doesn't work because it is a State-based model. This "knowledge" - this "idea" - is false. It is the idea of the State as a "mastermind."

"What cannot be known cannot be planned," said Hayek, about this "idea."

Liberty is not a "model."


Liberty frees the Individual Mind - to plan the future of its proprietor. With its own "fragment of knowledge" - and many uncertain guesses about the unknown and unknowable future. Free to "speculate."

The process of knowledge acquisition is itself largely "speculative" - as students attempt to guess which course of study will give them the best jobs and careers. Often, they don't succeed - and switch to learning other skills. With rapid technological obsolescence, new skills will have to be learnt many times in one lifetime - and all in The Market. This is the "knowledge economy" that is fast emerging. No one can design a "model" of Liberty. The Market, after all, surprises us each day with new offerings. Liberty will be full of surprises too.